| Season | Date | Opponent | H/A | Score | Result | Ground | Scorers |
|---|
| 1865-66 | Thu Mar 22, 1866 | Notts | H | 0-0 | Draw | Forest Recreation Ground | |
| Thu Apr 19, 1866 | Notts | A | 0-0 | Draw | | |
| 1866-67 | Thu Dec 13, 1866 | Notts | A | 1-1 | Draw | Meadows Cricket Ground | Lymbery (?) |
| Thu Feb 28, 1867 | Notts | H | 0-1 | Loss | Forest Recreation Ground | |
| 1867-68 | Sat Dec 28, 1867 | Sheffield Norfolk | H | 0-0 | Draw | Meadows Cricket Ground | |
| Tue Feb 25, 1868 | Sheffield Norfolk | A | 0-1 | Loss | Bramall Lane | |
| 1868-69 | Sat Dec 19, 1868 | Nottinghamshire XI | H | 2-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | ? (?, ?) |
| Sat Dec 26, 1868 | Sheffield Norfolk | H | 0-0 | Loss | Forest Recreation Ground | |
| Sat Jan 16, 1869 | Newark | A | 0-0 | Draw | London Road | |
| Sat Feb 06, 1869 | Nottingham Manufacturing Company | H | 0-0 | Loss | Meadows Cricket Ground | |
| Sat Feb 13, 1869 | Sheffield Norfolk | A | 1-4 | Loss | Newhall Gardens | ? (?) |
| Sat Mar 13, 1869 | Sawley | H | 2-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | ? (?, ?) |
| Sat Mar 20, 1869 | Sawley | A | 1-1 | Loss | | ? (?) |
| 1869-70 | Sat Oct 23, 1869 | Nottingham Forest XI | H | 1-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Revis (?) |
| Sat Nov 06, 1869 | Notts | H | 0-0 | Draw | | |
| Sat Nov 13, 1869 | Notts | H | 0-0 | Loss | Forest Cricket Ground | |
| Sat Dec 18, 1869 | Sawley | A | 1-1 | Draw | | White (?) |
| Tue Dec 21, 1869 | Nottingham Manufacturing Company | A | 0-0 | Win | | |
| Sat Jan 15, 1870 | Sheffield Norfolk | H | 0-3 | Loss | Trent Bridge | |
| Sat Feb 05, 1870 | South Derbyshire XI | A | 0-3 | Loss | Borrowash | |
| Sat Mar 05, 1870 | Derby Grammar | H | 5-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Mar 12, 1870 | Sheffield Norfolk | A | 1-3 | Loss | Queens Hotel Ground | ? (?) |
| Sat Mar 19, 1870 | Derby Grammar | A | 1-0 | Win | | ? (?) |
| Sat Mar 26, 1870 | South Derbyshire XI | H | 0-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | |
| Tue Apr 19, 1870 | Nottingham Forest XI | H | - | | | |
| 1870-71 | Sat Oct 22, 1870 | Nottingham Forest XI | H | 2-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | ? (?, ?) |
| Sat Nov 05, 1870 | Nottingham Manufacturing Company | H | 0-2 | Loss | Forest Recreation Ground | |
| Sat Nov 19, 1870 | Ockbrook | A | 2-2 | Draw | | ? (?, ?) |
| Sat Nov 26, 1870 | Derby Grammar | A | 0-0 | Win | | |
| Sat Dec 03, 1870 | St Andrews School (Derby) | H | 2-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | ? (?, ?) |
| Sat Dec 17, 1870 | Derby Grammar | H | 2-0 | Win | Forest Cricket Ground | ? (?, ?) |
| Sat Feb 11, 1871 | Sheffield Norfolk | A | 2-4 | Loss | | Widdowson (?), ? (?) |
| Sat Mar 04, 1871 | Sheffield Norfolk | H | 0-0 | Aba | Trent Bridge | |
| Sat Mar 11, 1871 | Notts County | H | 1-1 | Draw | | White (?) |
| Fri Mar 31, 1871 | Mansfield | H | 2-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Davies (?, ?) |
| 1871-72 | Sat Nov 04, 1871 | Ockbrook and Borrowash | A | 1-1 | Draw | | Lymbery (?) |
| Sat Nov 11, 1871 | Law Society | | 1-3 | Loss | Forest Recreation Ground | Hayes (?) |
| Sat Nov 18, 1871 | Mansfield | H | 1-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Hayes (?) |
| Sat Dec 02, 1871 | Chesterfield | H | 0-0 | Draw | Forest Recreation Ground | |
| Sat Dec 16, 1871 | Derby Grammar | H | 1-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Lymbery (?) |
| Sat Dec 30, 1871 | Nottinghamshire XI | A | 1-2 | Loss | | Widdowson (?) |
| Sat Jan 13, 1872 | Sheffield Norfolk | A | 1-5 | Loss | Norfolk Park | White (?) |
| Sat Jan 27, 1872 | Ockbrook and Borrowash | H | 3-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Hawksley (?, ?, 30) |
| Sat Feb 10, 1872 | Chesterfield | A | 1-1 | Draw | Recreation Ground, Chesterfield | Widdowson (?) |
| Tue Feb 13, 1872 | Notts County | A | 1-0 | Win | Meadows Cricket Ground | Hayes (89) |
| Sat Feb 17, 1872 | Trent College | A | 3-0 | Win | Trent Bridge | Hayes (?), Widdowson (?), Davies (?) |
| Sat Feb 24, 1872 | Notts County | H | 2-1 | Win | | Widdowson (?), Howitt (?) |
| Sat Mar 09, 1872 | Sheffield Norfolk | H | 1-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Davies (?) |
| Sat Mar 16, 1872 | Derby Grammar | A | 0-5 | Loss | | |
| 1872-73 | Sat Nov 02, 1872 | Mansfield | H | 0-0 | Draw | Forest Recreation Ground | |
| Sat Nov 16, 1872 | Derby Grammar | H | 1-1 | Draw | Forest Recreation Ground | ? (?) |
| Sat Nov 23, 1872 | Spondon School | H | 0-0 | Draw | Forest Recreation Ground | |
| Sat Nov 30, 1872 | Law Society | A | 0-0 | Draw | Meadows Cricket Ground | |
| Sat Dec 07, 1872 | Notts | H | 1-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Davies (?) |
| Sat Dec 14, 1872 | Stoke | A | 0-0 | Draw | | |
| Thu Jan 02, 1873 | Law Society | H | 2-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Rastall (?), Hayes (?) |
| Sat Jan 04, 1873 | Notts | A | 0-0 | Draw | Meadows Cricket Ground | |
| Sat Jan 11, 1873 | Ockbrook and Borrowash | A | 1-0 | Win | | Lymbery (?) |
| Sat Jan 18, 1873 | Burton on Trent | A | 1-1 | Draw | Burton Cricket Ground | Tomlinson (?) |
| Sat Jan 25, 1873 | Mansfield | A | 1-0 | Win | | ? (?) |
| Sat Feb 01, 1873 | Stoke | H | 3-1 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Davies (?), Widdowson (?, ?) |
| Sat Feb 08, 1873 | Derby Grammar | A | 0-0 | Draw | | |
| Sat Feb 15, 1873 | Ockbrook and Borrowash | H | 2-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Lymbery (?), ? (?) |
| Sat Mar 15, 1873 | Spondon School | H | 0-1 | Loss | Forest Recreation Ground | |
| 1873-74 | Sat Nov 01, 1873 | Derby Grammar | A | 1-6 | Loss | | Widdowson (?) |
| Sat Nov 15, 1873 | Derwent | H | 1-2 | Loss | Forest Recreation Ground | AW Borman (? OG) |
| Sat Nov 29, 1873 | Stoke | H | 2-1 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Howitt (?), Rastall (?) |
| Sat Dec 13, 1873 | Nottinghamshire XI | H | 1-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | ? (?) |
| Tue Dec 23, 1873 | Royal Engineers | H | 1-2 | Loss | Trent Bridge | Spencer (?) |
| Sat Dec 27, 1873 | Notts | H | 0-0 | Draw | Forest Recreation Ground | |
| Sat Jan 10, 1874 | Nottinghamshire XI | H | 1-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Goodyer (85) |
| Sat Jan 17, 1874 | Sheffield Norfolk | A | 1-7 | Loss | Bramall Lane | Pearson (?) |
| Sat Jan 31, 1874 | Mansfield | A | 2-0 | Win | | Revis (?), Goodyer (?) |
| Sat Feb 07, 1874 | Notts | A | 0-0 | Draw | Trent Bridge | |
| Sat Feb 21, 1874 | Sheffield Norfolk | H | 1-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Davies (30) |
| Sat Feb 28, 1874 | Mansfield | H | 3-1 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Goodyer (?), Howitt (?), ? (?) |
| Sat Mar 21, 1874 | Derwent | A | 1-1 | Draw | | Davies (?) |
| 1874-75 | Sat Oct 31, 1874 | Trent College | A | 1-3 | Loss | | ? (?) |
| Sat Nov 07, 1874 | Derwent | A | 1-3 | Loss | | Widdowson (?) |
| Sat Nov 14, 1874 | Notts | A | 0-0 | Draw | Trent Bridge | |
| Sat Nov 21, 1874 | Trent College | H | 1-0 | Win | | ? (?) |
| Sat Dec 05, 1874 | Notts County XI | A | 0-0 | Draw | | |
| Sat Dec 12, 1874 | Ambergate Wanderers | H | 0-0 | Draw | Gregory Ground | |
| Mon Dec 21, 1874 | Royal Engineers | | - | | | |
| Sat Jan 16, 1875 | Duffield | A | 2-0 | Win | | Revis (?), Widdowson (?) |
| Sat Jan 30, 1875 | Mansfield | H | 3-1 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?) |
| Tue Feb 09, 1875 | Notts | H | 5-1 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Feb 13, 1875 | Derwent | H | 2-0 | Win | | ? (?, ?) |
| Sat Feb 27, 1875 | Mansfield | H | 0-0 | Draw | Forest Recreation Ground | |
| Sat Mar 06, 1875 | Duffield | H | 4-1 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | ? (?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Mar 20, 1875 | Derby Grammar | H | 1-0 | Win | | Revis (?) |
| 1875-76 | Sat Nov 13, 1875 | Notts | H | 2-1 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | ? (?, ?) |
| Sat Dec 18, 1875 | Derwent | H | 3-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Goodyer (?), Revis (?), Widdowson (?) |
| Sat Jan 08, 1876 | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 0-5 | Loss | Forest Recreation Ground | |
| Sat Feb 05, 1876 | Derwent | A | 2-0 | Win | Racecourse Ground | ? (?, ?) |
| Sat Feb 12, 1876 | Birmingham City | A | 4-0 | Win | Aston Lower Grounds | ? (?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Feb 26, 1876 | Notts | A | 0-1 | Loss | Trent Bridge | |
| Sat Mar 11, 1876 | Birmingham | H | 0-0 | Draw | Forest Recreation Ground | |
| Sat Mar 18, 1876 | Sheffield Wednesday | A | 1-9 | Loss | Bramall Lane | ? (?) |
| 1876-77 | Sat Oct 21, 1876 | Nottingham Forest XI | | - | | | |
| Sat Nov 04, 1876 | Birmingham | H | 0-2 | Loss | Forest Recreation Ground | |
| Sat Nov 18, 1876 | Notts | H | 0-2 | Loss | Forest Recreation Ground | |
| Sat Dec 09, 1876 | Peterborough | A | 3-3 | Draw | | Goodyer (?), ? (?), Butler (10) |
| Sat Dec 16, 1876 | Nottingham Forest XI | | - | | | |
| Sat Dec 23, 1876 | Coventry City | A | 3-0 | Win | | Smith (?, ?), Turner (?) |
| Tue Dec 26, 1876 | Coventry City | H | 2-0 | Win | | ? (?, 30) |
| Sat Jan 13, 1877 | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 2-1 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Goodyer (?), Smith (?) |
| Sat Jan 27, 1877 | Sheffield Wednesday | A | 1-0 | Win | | ? (?) |
| Thu Feb 08, 1877 | Notts | A | 1-1 | Draw | | ? (?) |
| Tue Feb 13, 1877 | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 0-1 | Loss | Trent Bridge | |
| Sat Feb 24, 1877 | Birmingham City | A | 2-0 | Win | Aston Lower Grounds | ? (?, ?) |
| 1877-78 | Sat Nov 17, 1877 | Birmingham | H | 1-1 | Draw | Forest Recreation Ground | Widdowson (?) |
| Sat Dec 15, 1877 | Hertfordshire Rangers | H | 0-1 | Loss | | |
| Sat Jan 05, 1878 | Law Society | H | 7-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Keely (?, ?), Goodyer (?, ?), Butler (?), Rawson (?), ? (?) |
| Sat Jan 26, 1878 | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 4-1 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Rawson (?), Widdowson (?), Golland (?), Goodyer (?) |
| Sat Feb 16, 1878 | Glasgow Rangers | H | 2-4 | Loss | Trent Bridge | Golland (?, ?) |
| Thu Feb 21, 1878 | Spital | H | 1-2 | Loss | Forest Recreation Ground | Jardine (?) |
| Sat Feb 23, 1878 | Birmingham | A | 1-1 | Draw | Aston Lower Grounds | Smith (?) |
| Sat Mar 02, 1878 | Southwell | A | 3-2 | Win | | ? (?, ?, 5) |
| Tue Mar 05, 1878 | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 0-1 | Loss | Trent Bridge | |
| Sat Mar 09, 1878 | Birmingham | A | 3-0 | Win | Aston Lower Grounds | Goodyer (?, ?), Smith (?) |
| Sat Mar 16, 1878 | Stoke | A | 0-1 | Loss | | |
| Sat Apr 06, 1878 | Derby Town | H | 1-0 | Win | | Turner (?) |
| Sat Apr 20, 1878 | Glasgow Rangers | A | 0-2 | Loss | | |
| Mon Apr 22, 1878 | Ayr Thistle | A | 3-0 | Win | Robbsland Park | ? (?, ?, ?) |
| 1878-79 | Sat Oct 12, 1878 | Stoke | H | 2-1 | Win | | Luntley (?), Goodyer (3) |
| Sat Oct 19, 1878 | Derby Town | H | 0-0 | Draw | Forest Recreation Ground | |
| Sat Oct 26, 1878 | Glasgow Rangers | H | 0-2 | Loss | Gregory Ground | |
| Mon Oct 28, 1878 | Birmingham | A | 1-2 | Loss | | ? (?) |
| Sat Nov 09, 1878 | Birmingham | A | 3-1 | Win | Aston Lower Grounds | Widdowson (?, ?), Turner (?) |
| Sat Nov 30, 1878 | Chesterfield | H | 4-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Goodyer (?, ?), Smith (?), Slack (? OG) |
| Sat Dec 07, 1878 | Sheffield Wednesday | A | 0-1 | Loss | Sheaf House | |
| Wed Dec 11, 1878 | Law Society | H | 7-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Widdowson (?), Danks (? OG), ? (?, ?, ?, ?), Warner (? OG) |
| Sat Jan 18, 1879 | Edinburgh University | H | 4-1 | Win | Trent Bridge | Earp (?), Widdowson (?, ?), Smith (?) |
| Sat Feb 08, 1879 | Chesterfield | A | 6-0 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Feb 15, 1879 | Birmingham | H | 6-1 | Win | Trent Bridge | Widdowson (?, ?, ?, ?, 36), Smith (?) |
| Sat Feb 22, 1879 | Derby Town | A | 0-3 | Loss | County Ground, Derby | |
| Sat Mar 08, 1879 | Chesterfield | H | 5-1 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Smith (?), Widdowson (?, ?), Goodyer (?), Turner (?) |
| Sat Mar 29, 1879 | Spital | A | 1-2 | Loss | Forest Recreation Ground | ? (?) |
| Sat Apr 12, 1879 | Glasgow Rangers | A | 0-3 | Loss | | |
| Sat Apr 19, 1879 | Stoke | A | 0-0 | Draw | Forest Recreation Ground | |
| 1879-80 | Sat Sep 27, 1879 | Nottinghamshire XI | A | 6-0 | Win | Castle Cricket Ground | Johnstone (?), Goodyer (?, ?, ?), Earp (?), Widdowson (?) |
| Sat Oct 04, 1879 | Stoke | H | 4-0 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Oct 18, 1879 | Darwen | A | 3-1 | Win | | Smith (?), ? (?, ?) |
| Sat Oct 25, 1879 | Birmingham | H | 6-0 | Win | Trent Bridge | Goodyer (?), Widdowson (?, ?, 44), Smith (?, 28) |
| Sat Nov 01, 1879 | Edinburgh University | H | 6-1 | Win | Trent Bridge | Goodyer (?), Widdowson (?, ?, ?, ?), Smith (?) |
| Sat Dec 27, 1879 | Blackburn Rovers | H | 1-1 | Draw | Trent Bridge | Turner (?) |
| Sat Jan 10, 1880 | Wednesbury Strollers | H | 4-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Turner (?), Earp (?), Lindley (?), JJ Knowles (? OG) |
| Sat Jan 17, 1880 | Notts County | H | 7-1 | Win | Trent Bridge | ? (?), Earp (?, ?), Goodyer (?, ?, ?), Holroyd (?) |
| Sat Jan 24, 1880 | Sheffield FC | H | 3-2 | Win | Trent Bridge | Smith (?), Widdowson (?, ?) |
| Sat Feb 07, 1880 | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 2-0 | Win | Trent Bridge | Earp (?), Turner (?) |
| Tue Feb 10, 1880 | Scottish Canadian | H | 0-2 | Loss | Trent Bridge | |
| Sat Feb 21, 1880 | Sheffield Wednesday | A | 0-1 | Loss | Sheaf House | |
| Sat Feb 28, 1880 | Darwen | H | 5-0 | Win | Trent Bridge | Turner (?, ?), Smith (?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Mar 13, 1880 | Stoke | A | 1-3 | Loss | Victoria Ground | ? (?) |
| Mon Mar 29, 1880 | Edinburgh University | A | 1-2 | Loss | Powder Hall | Smith (89) |
| Tue Mar 30, 1880 | Blackburn Rovers | A | 1-5 | Loss | Ewood Park | ? (85) |
| 1880-81 | Sat Oct 02, 1880 | Aston Villa | A | 0-4 | Loss | Villa Park | |
| Sat Oct 09, 1880 | Wednesbury Strollers | A | 3-0 | Win | Trapezium | ? (?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Oct 16, 1880 | Notts County | H | 4-0 | Win | Trent Bridge | Widdowson (?, ?, ?), Earp (?) |
| Sat Oct 23, 1880 | Darwen | A | 4-4 | Draw | | Turner (?, ?), Widdowson (?, ?) |
| Sat Oct 30, 1880 | Glasgow Rangers | H | 2-1 | Win | Trent Bridge | Earp (?, ?) |
| Sat Nov 13, 1880 | Aston Villa | H | 0-2 | Loss | Trent Bridge | |
| Sat Nov 20, 1880 | Nottingham Forest XI | H | 2-4 | Loss | | ? (?, ?) |
| Sat Nov 27, 1880 | Nottingham Forest XI | H | - | | | |
| Thu Dec 09, 1880 | Cambridge University | H | 3-1 | Win | Trent Bridge | Widdowson (?), Smith (?), Johnson (?) |
| Sat Dec 11, 1880 | Glasgow Rangers | A | 2-2 | Draw | Kinning Park | ? (?), Widdowson (?) |
| Mon Dec 27, 1880 | Blackburn Rovers | H | 0-4 | Loss | Trent Bridge | |
| Sat Jan 01, 1881 | Sheffield FC | A | 1-2 | Loss | Bramall Lane | Widdowson (?) |
| Sat Jan 08, 1881 | Leicestershire Rangers | H | 12-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | Wright (?, ?, ?), Widdowson (?, ?), Caborn (?), Norman (?), Earp (?, ?, ?, 10), ? (?) |
| Sat Jan 29, 1881 | Darwen | H | 3-0 | Win | Trent Bridge | Widdowson (?), Wright (?), Norman (?) |
| Sat Feb 12, 1881 | South Derbyshire XI | H | 2-0 | Win | Trent Bridge | ? (?), Parr (?) |
| Sat Feb 19, 1881 | Vale of Leven | H | 2-0 | Win | Trent Bridge | Widdowson (?), Unwin (?) |
| Sat Feb 26, 1881 | Clapham Rovers | H | 3-0 | Win | Trent Bridge | Widdowson (?, ?, ?) |
| Tue Mar 01, 1881 | Sheffield FC | H | 1-0 | Win | Trent Bridge | Gunn (?) |
| Sat Mar 05, 1881 | Notts County | A | 0-1 | Loss | Castle Cricket Ground | |
| Sat Mar 12, 1881 | Blackburn Rovers | A | 3-3 | Draw | Castle Cricket Ground | Billyeald (?), ? (?), Earp (7) |
| Sat Mar 19, 1881 | South Derbyshire XI | A | 2-2 | Draw | County Ground, Derby | ? (?, ?) |
| Sat Apr 09, 1881 | South Derbyshire XI | A | 17-0 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| 1881-82 | Sat Jul 23, 1881 | Aston Villa | A | 1-1 | Draw | | ? (?) |
| Sat Aug 27, 1881 | Wollaton | A | 10-1 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Mon Sep 05, 1881 | Southwell | A | 9-1 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Sep 17, 1881 | Brigg Britannia | A | 6-0 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Sep 24, 1881 | Small Heath | A | 2-1 | Win | | ? (?, ?) |
| Sat Oct 01, 1881 | Small Heath | H | 3-2 | Win | Trent Bridge | Widdowson (?, ?), Norman (?) |
| Fri Oct 07, 1881 | Nottinghamshire XI | H | 4-1 | Win | Castle Cricket Ground | ? (?), Widdowson (?), Norman (?), Earp (?) |
| Sat Oct 15, 1881 | Blackburn Olympic | H | 3-0 | Win | Castle Cricket Ground | Widdowson (?, ?, ?) |
| Thu Oct 20, 1881 | Nottingham Bank | H | 5-0 | Win | Forest Recreation Ground | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, 10) |
| Sat Oct 22, 1881 | Darwen | A | 1-0 | Win | Barley Bank | Gowthorpe (?) |
| Mon Oct 24, 1881 | Kettering Town | A | 5-1 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Oct 29, 1881 | Glasgow Rangers | H | 0-0 | Draw | Trent Bridge | |
| Sat Nov 12, 1881 | Walsall | H | 8-3 | Win | Trent Bridge | Norman (?, ?), Widdowson (?, ?, ?), Gowthorpe (?), Gunn (?, ?) |
| Sat Dec 03, 1881 | Accrington | H | 3-3 | Draw | Trent Bridge | Earp (?, ?), Gowthorpe (?) |
| Thu Dec 15, 1881 | Cambridge University | H | 4-2 | Win | Trent Bridge | Gunn (?, ?), Norman (?), Earp (?) |
| Sat Dec 17, 1881 | Notts | H | 0-5 | Loss | Trent Bridge | |
| Sat Dec 24, 1881 | Blackburn Rovers | H | 0-2 | Loss | Trent Bridge | |
| Sat Dec 31, 1881 | Alexandra Athletic | H | 1-0 | Win | Trent Bridge | Norman (?) |
| Sat Jan 21, 1882 | Darwen | H | 4-5 | Loss | Trent Bridge | Norman (?, ?), Gunn (?), Parr (?) |
| Sat Feb 04, 1882 | Wednesbury Strollers | H | 15-0 | Win | Trent Bridge | Billyeald (?), Norman (?, ?, ?, ?), Widdowson (?, ?, ?, ?, ?), Parr (?), Earp (?, ?, ?), Hill (?) |
| Sat Feb 11, 1882 | Notts | A | 2-1 | Win | Castle Cricket Ground | Norman (?), Earp (?) |
| Tue Feb 21, 1882 | Heart Of Midlothian | H | 2-1 | Win | Trent Bridge | Widdowson (?, ?) |
| Sat Mar 04, 1882 | Bolton Wanderers | H | 2-1 | Win | Trent Bridge | Widdowson (?), Norman (?) |
| Sat Mar 11, 1882 | Derby Town | H | 4-0 | Win | Trent Bridge | Norman (?), Cox (?, ?), Earp (?) |
| Sat Mar 18, 1882 | Nottinghamshire XI | H | 4-1 | Win | Trent Bridge | Widdowson (?), Smith (?), Fletcher (?), Sands (?) |
| Sat Apr 08, 1882 | Accrington | A | 5-3 | Win | Trent Bridge | Widdowson (?, ?), Luntley (?, ?), Hill (?) |
| Mon Apr 10, 1882 | Blackburn Olympic | A | 4-1 | Win | | Hill (?, ?), Brierley (? OG), Unwin (?) |
| 1882-83 | Sat Aug 26, 1882 | Wollaton | A | 2-3 | Loss | | ? (?, ?) |
| Sat Sep 02, 1882 | Shepshed | A | 4-0 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Sep 23, 1882 | Small Heath | A | 4-0 | Win | | Norman (?, ?), Danks (?), Parr (?) |
| Sat Sep 30, 1882 | Halliwell | A | 1-3 | Loss | | Hill (?) |
| Fri Oct 06, 1882 | Nottinghamshire XI | H | 5-0 | Win | | Brown (?, ?), Hill (?), Fletcher (?), Norman (30) |
| Sat Oct 07, 1882 | Stoke | H | 2-4 | Loss | Trent Bridge | Danks (?), Norman (?) |
| Sat Oct 14, 1882 | Blackburn Olympic | H | 1-0 | Win | Trent Bridge | Norman (?) |
| Sat Oct 21, 1882 | Blackburn Rovers | A | 0-6 | Loss | Leamington Road | |
| Sat Nov 11, 1882 | Bolton Wanderers | A | 1-9 | Loss | | Bausor (?) |
| Sat Nov 18, 1882 | Sheffield FC | A | 5-1 | Win | Bramall Lane | Bausor (?, ?), Danks (?), Parr (?), Fletcher (?) |
| Tue Dec 26, 1882 | Bolton Wanderers | H | 3-1 | Win | Trent Bridge | Fletcher (?, ?), Unwin (?) |
| Wed Dec 27, 1882 | Sheffield FC | H | 0-5 | Loss | Trent Bridge | |
| Sat Jan 20, 1883 | Notts | H | 1-1 | Draw | Trent Bridge | Earp (?) |
| Sat Jan 27, 1883 | Clapham Rovers | A | 2-1 | Win | Kennington Oval | Widdowson (?), Earp (?) |
| Sat Feb 03, 1883 | Darwen | H | 2-1 | Win | Trent Bridge | Parr (?), Widdowson (?) |
| Tue Feb 06, 1883 | Blackburn Rovers | H | 0-0 | Draw | Trent Bridge | |
| Sat Feb 17, 1883 | Stafford Road | H | 6-1 | Win | Trent Bridge | Lindley (?, ?, ?), Danks (?), Billyeald (?), ? (?) |
| Sat Feb 24, 1883 | Stoke | A | 7-2 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Mar 24, 1883 | Darwen | A | 2-4 | Loss | | ? (?, ?) |
| Mon Mar 26, 1883 | Stoke | A | 8-2 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Apr 07, 1883 | Small Heath | A | 2-0 | Win | | Luntley (?, ?) |
| Sat May 05, 1883 | Grimsby Town | A | 2-1 | Win | Cleethorpes Road | ? (?, ?) |
| 1883-84 | Sat Sep 22, 1883 | Small Heath | H | 3-2 | Win | Gregory Ground | Earp (?), Luntley (30), Fox (53) |
| Sat Oct 13, 1883 | Sheffield FC | H | 9-1 | Win | Parkside Ground | Widdowson (?), Earp (?), Fletcher (?), Lindley (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Oct 20, 1883 | Notts County | H | 0-0 | Draw | Parkside Ground | |
| Sat Oct 27, 1883 | Stoke | H | 2-1 | Win | Parkside Ground | Lindley (?), Fox (?) |
| Sat Nov 03, 1883 | Swifts | H | 6-1 | Win | Parkside Ground | Luntley (?, ?, ?, ?), Davis (?, ?) |
| Sat Nov 17, 1883 | Sheffield Attercliffe | H | 5-0 | Win | Parkside Ground | Fletcher (?), Davis (?), Lindley (?, 10), Luntley (?) |
| Sat Nov 24, 1883 | Dumbarton | H | 2-3 | Loss | Parkside Ground | Widdowson (?, ?) |
| Sat Dec 08, 1883 | Darwen | H | 8-0 | Win | Parkside Ground | Lindley (?, ?, ?), Barlow (?, ?, ?), Fox (?), ? (?) |
| Sat Dec 22, 1883 | Blackburn Rovers | H | 2-2 | Draw | Parkside Ground | Widdowson (?), Luntley (20) |
| Wed Dec 26, 1883 | Notts | A | 1-5 | Loss | | Lindley (?) |
| Mon Jan 07, 1884 | Cambridge University | H | 1-2 | Loss | Parkside Ground | Barlow (?) |
| Sat Jan 19, 1884 | Sheffield Attercliffe | A | 8-1 | Win | Old Forge Ground | Leighton (?), Barlow (?), Lindley (?, ?, ?, ?), Fox (?), Fulton (5) |
| Sat Jan 26, 1884 | Walsall Town Swifts | H | 1-1 | Draw | Parkside Ground | Earp (?) |
| Sat Feb 02, 1884 | Dumbarton | A | 1-3 | Loss | Boghead | Miller (? OG) |
| Sat Feb 23, 1884 | Small Heath | A | 2-3 | Loss | | ? (?, ?) |
| Sat Mar 08, 1884 | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 0-2 | Loss | Parkside Ground | |
| Sat Mar 29, 1884 | Aston Villa | H | 0-2 | Loss | Parkside Ground | |
| 1884-85 | Sat Sep 27, 1884 | Stoke | A | 4-6 | Loss | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Oct 04, 1884 | Bolton Association | H | 5-1 | Win | Parkside Ground | Wilkinson (?, ?), Unwin (?), Brown (?), Smith (?) |
| Sat Oct 11, 1884 | Lincoln City | A | 4-2 | Win | John O'Gaunts | Mason (?), Wilkinson (?, ?), ? (?) |
| Sat Oct 18, 1884 | Walsall Town Swifts | A | 1-3 | Loss | The Chuckery | Hawkes (?) |
| Sat Oct 25, 1884 | Blackburn Rovers | A | 1-3 | Loss | Leamington Road | Simkins (?) |
| Sat Nov 15, 1884 | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 0-5 | Loss | Parkside Ground | |
| Sat Nov 22, 1884 | Sheffield FC | H | 6-0 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Nov 29, 1884 | Walsall Town Swifts | H | 0-0 | Draw | Parkside Ground | |
| Sat Dec 13, 1884 | Burton Swifts | H | 4-1 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Dec 20, 1884 | Walsall | H | 1-1 | Draw | Parkside Ground | Lindley (?) |
| Fri Dec 26, 1884 | Notts | H | 3-0 | Win | Trent Bridge | Lindley (?, ?, ?) |
| Thu Jan 08, 1885 | London Casuals | H | 3-0 | Win | Trent Bridge | Lindley (?), Fox (?), Unwin (?) |
| Sat Jan 10, 1885 | Small Heath Alliance | H | 3-0 | Win | Parkside Ground | Lindley (?), Unwin (?), Tutin (?) |
| Sat Jan 31, 1885 | Derby County | H | 1-6 | Loss | Parkside Ground | ? (?) |
| Sat Feb 14, 1885 | Sheffield Wednesday | A | 5-0 | Win | Old Forge Ground | Fox (?), Walker (?, ?), Leighton (?), Danks (?) |
| Wed Feb 18, 1885 | Great Lever | H | 3-2 | Win | Trent Bridge | Unwin (?), ? (?), Leighton (?) |
| Sat Feb 28, 1885 | Blackburn Rovers | H | 3-0 | Win | Parkside Ground | Unwin (?, ?), Danks (?) |
| Sat Mar 21, 1885 | Basford Rovers | N | 6-1 | Win | | Lindley (?, ?, ?), Widdowson (?), Fox (?, ?) |
| Mon Apr 06, 1885 | Derby County | A | 1-1 | Draw | County Ground, Derby | ? (?) |
| Sat Apr 11, 1885 | Small Heath Alliance | A | - | Draw | | |
| Sat Apr 18, 1885 | Notts County | A | 2-3 | Loss | Castle Cricket Ground | ? (?, ?) |
| 1885-86 | Sat Sep 26, 1885 | Stoke On Trent | H | 4-1 | Win | Gregory Ground | Fox (?), Lindley (?, ?), Unwin (?) |
| Sat Oct 03, 1885 | Walsall Town Swifts | H | 3-1 | Win | Gregory Ground | Danks (?), Leighton (?, ?) |
| Sat Oct 10, 1885 | Wednesbury Old Athletic | H | 2-2 | Draw | Gregory Ground | Fox (?), Leighton (?) |
| Sat Oct 24, 1885 | Aston Villa | H | 0-0 | Draw | Gregory Ground | |
| Sat Nov 07, 1885 | Cambridge University | A | 1-5 | Loss | | Fox (?) |
| Sat Nov 14, 1885 | Blackburn Rovers | H | 4-0 | Win | Gregory Ground | Ward (?), Tutin (?, ?), Forrest (? OG) |
| Sat Nov 28, 1885 | Notts | H | 1-4 | Loss | Gregory Ground | ? (?) |
| Sat Dec 05, 1885 | Derby County | H | 2-1 | Win | Gregory Ground | Billyeald (?), Danks (?) |
| Sat Dec 19, 1885 | Sheffield Wednesday | A | 1-1 | Draw | Bramall Lane | Tutin (?) |
| Sat Dec 26, 1885 | Crewe Alexandra | A | 3-2 | Win | | Tutin (?), Osborne (? OG), ? (?) |
| Thu Dec 31, 1885 | Casuals | H | 2-0 | Win | Gregory Ground | Leighton (?), Fox (80) |
| Sat Jan 02, 1886 | Walsall Town Swifts | H | 4-1 | Win | | Billyeald (?), Leighton (?), Unwin (?), Profitt (? OG) |
| Sat Jan 09, 1886 | Derby County | A | 0-1 | Loss | | |
| Sat Jan 16, 1886 | Notts | A | 0-5 | Loss | Trent Bridge | |
| Sat Jan 23, 1886 | Bolton Wanderers | H | 0-7 | Loss | Gregory Ground | |
| Sat Jan 30, 1886 | Preston North End | H | 1-4 | Loss | Gregory Ground | Jeffries (?) |
| Sat Feb 06, 1886 | Halliwell | H | 0-2 | Loss | Gregory Ground | |
| Sat Feb 20, 1886 | West Bromwich Albion | A | 0-1 | Loss | | |
| Sat Feb 27, 1886 | Glasgow Rangers | H | 2-2 | Draw | Gregory Ground | Fox (?), Unwin (?) |
| Sat Mar 13, 1886 | Small Heath Alliance | H | 1-2 | Loss | Gregory Ground | Fox (?) |
| Sat Mar 13, 1886 | Stoke On Trent | A | 1-0 | Win | | ? (?) |
| Sat Mar 20, 1886 | Sheffield FC | H | 6-0 | Win | Gregory Ground | Davis (?, 15), Fox (?, 40), Unwin (?, ?) |
| Sat Apr 10, 1886 | Preston North End | A | 0-7 | Loss | | |
| Fri Apr 23, 1886 | Burnley | A | 4-2 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Apr 24, 1886 | Glasgow Rangers | A | 1-2 | Loss | Kinning Park | Leighton (?) |
| Mon Apr 26, 1886 | Newcastle and District | A | 5-1 | Win | Tyne Ground | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| 1886-87 | Sat Sep 18, 1886 | Small Heath Alliance | A | 2-0 | Win | Coventry Road | Lindley (?), Fox (?) |
| Sat Sep 25, 1886 | Wednesbury Old Athletic | H | 10-0 | Win | Gregory Ground | Tutin (?, ?, ?), Fox (?, ?), Leighton (?), Lindley (?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Oct 02, 1886 | Walsall Town Swifts | H | 3-0 | Win | Gregory Ground | Tutin (?), Jeffries (?), Norman (?) |
| Thu Oct 07, 1886 | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 4-1 | Win | Gregory Ground | Tutin (?, ?), Leighton (?), Lindley (?) |
| Sat Oct 09, 1886 | Staveley | H | 2-1 | Win | Gregory Ground | Jeffries (?), Tutin (?) |
| Sat Oct 16, 1886 | Stoke | A | 0-2 | Loss | | |
| Sat Oct 23, 1886 | Accrington | H | 1-4 | Loss | Gregory Ground | Fox (?) |
| Sat Nov 06, 1886 | Cambridge University | H | 3-0 | Win | Gregory Ground | Leighton (?, ?), Norman (?) |
| Mon Dec 27, 1886 | Notts County | A | 2-0 | Win | Trent Bridge | Fox (?), Danks (?) |
| Tue Dec 28, 1886 | Stoke On Trent | H | 2-0 | Aba | Gregory Ground | Lindley (10), Danks (20) |
| Sat Jan 01, 1887 | Accrington | A | 2-4 | Loss | | Jeffries (?), Fox (?) |
| Sat Jan 22, 1887 | Birmingham Excelsior | H | 6-3 | Win | Gregory Ground | Pike (?), Leighton (?, ?), Norman (?), Tutin (?, ?) |
| Sat Jan 29, 1887 | Cambridge University | A | 0-2 | Loss | Corpus Ground | |
| Sat Feb 12, 1887 | Notts County | H | 1-2 | Loss | Gregory Ground | ? (?) |
| Sat Feb 19, 1887 | Derby County | A | 0-2 | Loss | | |
| Tue Feb 22, 1887 | Burnley | H | 1-1 | Draw | Gregory Ground | ? (?) |
| Sat Mar 05, 1887 | Birmingham Excelsior | A | 2-2 | Draw | Fentham Road | Dunnicliff (?, ?) |
| Sat Mar 12, 1887 | Derby County | H | 2-1 | Win | | Fox (?), Danks (?) |
| Sat Mar 19, 1887 | Notts County | A | 1-1 | Draw | Castle Cricket Ground | Danks (?) |
| Sat Mar 26, 1887 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | H | 0-4 | Loss | Gregory Ground | |
| Fri Apr 08, 1887 | Burnley | A | 0-0 | Draw | Turf Moor | |
| Sat Apr 09, 1887 | Glasgow Rangers | A | 0-1 | Loss | Catkin Park | |
| Mon Apr 11, 1887 | Bootle | A | 2-1 | Win | | Jackson (?), ? (?) |
| 1887-88 | Sat Sep 17, 1887 | Preston North End | A | 2-5 | Loss | | Lindley (?), Danks (?) |
| Sat Sep 24, 1887 | Wednesbury Old Athletic | H | 3-2 | Win | Gregory Ground | Fox (?), Winfield (?, ?) |
| Sat Oct 01, 1887 | Long Eaton Rangers | H | 1-0 | Win | Gregory Ground | Liddell (?) |
| Thu Oct 06, 1887 | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 2-1 | Win | Gregory Ground | Winfield (?), Brayshaw (? OG) |
| Sat Oct 08, 1887 | Stoke | H | 2-1 | Win | Gregory Ground | Fox (?), Lindley (?) |
| Sat Oct 22, 1887 | Burslem Port Vale | H | 1-1 | Draw | Gregory Ground | Shaw (?) |
| Sat Nov 12, 1887 | Lincoln City | A | 1-1 | Draw | John O'Gaunts | ? (?) |
| Thu Nov 17, 1887 | Corinthians | H | 2-1 | Win | | Jackson (?), Leighton (?) |
| Sat Dec 03, 1887 | Notts | H | 0-1 | Loss | Gregory Ground | |
| Sat Dec 10, 1887 | Accrington | H | 2-0 | Win | Gregory Ground | Pike (?), Winfield (?) |
| Mon Dec 26, 1887 | Notts | A | 0-0 | Draw | | |
| Tue Dec 27, 1887 | Bolton Wanderers | H | 3-2 | Win | Gregory Ground | Danks (?), Burton (?), Shaw (?) |
| Sat Jan 14, 1888 | Preston North End | H | 2-1 | Win | | Burton (?), Pike (?) |
| Sat Jan 21, 1888 | Grimsby Town | H | 2-0 | Win | Gregory Ground | Norman (?), Tutin (?) |
| Sat Jan 28, 1888 | Cambridge University | A | 1-5 | Loss | Clare College Ground | Leighton (?) |
| Sat Feb 04, 1888 | Lincoln City | H | 2-0 | Win | Gregory Ground | Leighton (?), Weightman (?) |
| Tue Feb 14, 1888 | Burnley | H | 1-2 | Loss | Gregory Ground | Lindley (?) |
| Sat Feb 18, 1888 | Cambridge University | H | 0-3 | Loss | Gregory Ground | |
| Sat Mar 03, 1888 | Stoke On Trent | A | 0-3 | Loss | | |
| Sat Mar 10, 1888 | Aston Unity | H | 4-3 | Win | Gregory Ground | Parr (?, ?), Leighton (?, ?) |
| Fri Mar 30, 1888 | Burnley | A | 1-3 | Loss | | Townsley (? OG) |
| Sat Mar 31, 1888 | Bolton Wanderers | A | 1-3 | Loss | | Guttridge (?) |
| Mon Apr 02, 1888 | Bootle | A | 1-4 | Loss | | ? (?) |
| Sat Apr 21, 1888 | Burslem Port Vale | A | 2-7 | Loss | | ? (?, ?) |
| 1888-89 | Sat Sep 08, 1888 | Sheffield Wednesday | A | 2-2 | Draw | Olive Grove | Lindley (?), ? (?) |
| Sat Sep 15, 1888 | Mitchell St. George's | A | 1-7 | Loss | Cape Hill | Shaw (? OG) |
| Sat Sep 22, 1888 | Warwick County | H | 5-0 | Win | Gregory Ground | Tutin (?), Lindley (?, ?), Fox (?, ?) |
| Sat Sep 29, 1888 | Sheffield FC | H | 8-1 | Win | Gregory Ground | Burton (?), Fox (?, 50), Tutin (?, ?), Lindley (?, 15), Leighton (12) |
| Thu Oct 04, 1888 | Aston Villa | H | 1-2 | Loss | Gregory Ground | Burton (?) |
| Sat Oct 06, 1888 | Long Eaton Rangers | H | 0-2 | Loss | Gregory Ground | |
| Sat Oct 20, 1888 | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 1-3 | Loss | Gregory Ground | Fox (?) |
| Thu Oct 25, 1888 | Preston North End | H | 0-2 | Loss | Gregory Ground | |
| Sat Oct 27, 1888 | Mitchell St. George's | H | 1-0 | Win | Gregory Ground | Norman (?) |
| Sat Nov 03, 1888 | Hereford United | A | 6-0 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Nov 10, 1888 | Clapton | A | 2-2 | Draw | | Lindley (?, ?) |
| Sat Nov 17, 1888 | Derby County | A | 0-3 | Loss | | |
| Sat Nov 24, 1888 | Blackburn Olympic | H | 2-3 | Loss | Gregory Ground | Pike (?), Harker (?) |
| Sat Dec 01, 1888 | Notts County | H | 3-0 | Win | Gregory Ground | Lindley (?, ?), Guttridge (? OG) |
| Sat Dec 08, 1888 | Walsall Town Swifts | H | 1-2 | Loss | Gregory Ground | Tolley (88) |
| Sat Dec 15, 1888 | Sheffield Heeley | H | 4-1 | Win | Gregory Ground | Tolley (?, ?), Jeacock (?), Burton (12) |
| Sat Dec 22, 1888 | Derby Junction | H | 3-0 | Win | Gregory Ground | Hind (? OG), Tutin (?), Jeacock (?) |
| Wed Dec 26, 1888 | Notts County | A | 1-4 | Loss | | ? (?) |
| Sat Dec 29, 1888 | Casuals | H | 1-4 | Loss | Gregory Ground | Burton (?) |
| Sat Jan 05, 1889 | Derby Junction | A | 2-1 | Win | Arboretum | Burton (?, ?) |
| Sat Jan 12, 1889 | Sheffield FC | A | 1-0 | Win | | Clarke (?) |
| Sat Jan 19, 1889 | Glasgow Rangers | H | 2-1 | Win | Gregory Ground | Tutin (?, ?) |
| Sat Jan 26, 1889 | Corinthians | A | 1-2 | Loss | The Oval | Jackson (?) |
| Sat Feb 09, 1889 | Linfield Athletic | H | 1-3 | Loss | Ulster Ground | Tutin (?) |
| Mon Mar 04, 1889 | Stoke | H | 1-2 | Loss | Gregory Ground | Tolley (?) |
| Sat Mar 09, 1889 | Newton Heath | H | 2-2 | Draw | Gregory Ground | ? (?, ?) |
| Sat Mar 16, 1889 | Small Heath | A | 0-3 | Loss | | |
| Sat Mar 23, 1889 | Newton Heath | A | 1-3 | Loss | | Pike (?) |
| Mon Mar 25, 1889 | Notts Rangers | H | 0-2 | Loss | Gregory Ground | |
| Sat Apr 06, 1889 | Clapton | H | 3-2 | Win | Gregory Ground | Shaw (?, ?), Tutin (?) |
| Fri Apr 19, 1889 | Sunderland Albion | A | 0-5 | Loss | Blue House Field | |
| Sat Apr 20, 1889 | Glasgow Rangers | A | 0-2 | Loss | Ibrox | |
| Mon Apr 22, 1889 | Bootle | A | 0-5 | Loss | | |
| 1889-90 | Sat Sep 14, 1889 | Halliwell | H | 2-3 | Loss | Gregory Ground | ? (?, ?) |
| Thu Oct 24, 1889 | Preston North End | H | 2-1 | Win | Gregory Ground | ? (?, ?) |
| Sat Nov 16, 1889 | Casuals | H | 3-1 | Win | Gregory Ground | ? (?, ?, ?) |
| Mon Nov 25, 1889 | Sheffield United | A | 0-2 | Loss | | |
| Sat Nov 30, 1889 | Notts | H | 2-4 | Loss | Gregory Ground | ? (?, ?) |
| Sat Dec 21, 1889 | Clapton | A | 0-1 | Loss | | |
| Thu Dec 26, 1889 | Notts | A | 1-1 | Draw | Trent Bridge | Jardine (?) |
| Sat Jan 25, 1890 | Everton | A | 0-7 | Loss | | |
| Sat Feb 08, 1890 | Chatham | A | 1-1 | Draw | | ? (?) |
| Sat Mar 01, 1890 | Sheffield United | A | 2-1 | Win | | ? (?, ?) |
| Sat Mar 08, 1890 | Small Heath | A | 0-12 | Loss | Muntz Street | |
| Sat Mar 15, 1890 | Chatham | H | 2-0 | Win | Gregory Ground | ? (?, ?) |
| 1890-91 | Mon Sep 01, 1890 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | A | 0-1 | Loss | | |
| Wed Sep 03, 1890 | Notts Olympic | H | 4-0 | Win | Gregory Ground | ? (?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Mon Sep 15, 1890 | Heart Of Midlothian | A | 0-1 | Loss | | |
| Mon Sep 29, 1890 | Sheffield United | A | 2-1 | Win | | ? (?, ?) |
| Thu Oct 02, 1890 | Queen's Park | H | 4-2 | Win | Town Ground | Smith (?, ?), Higgins (?), Pike (?) |
| Fri Oct 03, 1890 | Stoke | H | 2-2 | Draw | Town Ground | Lindley (?), Pike (?) |
| Thu Oct 23, 1890 | Aston Villa | H | 3-0 | Win | Town Ground | ? (?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Oct 25, 1890 | Clapton | A | 4-0 | Win | Spotted Dog Ground | Pike (?), Higgins (?), May (?), Russell (10) |
| Thu Nov 13, 1890 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | H | 5-0 | Win | Town Ground | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Nov 15, 1890 | West Bromwich Albion | A | 2-2 | Draw | | Higgins (?), ? (?) |
| Thu Nov 27, 1890 | Bolton Wanderers | H | 7-1 | Win | Town Ground | Higgins (?, ?, ?), Pike (?), May (?, ?), Smith (?) |
| Sat Nov 29, 1890 | Stoke | A | 1-2 | Loss | | ? (?) |
| Sat Dec 06, 1890 | Clyde | A | 5-2 | Win | | McCallum (?), Smith (?, ?), Russell (?), ? (?) |
| Thu Dec 18, 1890 | Burnley | H | 3-4 | Loss | Town Ground | ? (?, ?, ?) |
| Fri Dec 26, 1890 | Notts | A | 0-0 | Draw | | |
| Thu Jan 01, 1891 | Bolton Wanderers | A | 0-3 | Loss | | |
| Sat Jan 03, 1891 | Heart Of Midlothian | H | 8-2 | Win | Town Ground | Smith (?, ?, ?), Russell (?), Rowan (?), Shaw (?), Higgins (?, ?) |
| Sat Jan 10, 1891 | Glasgow Rangers | A | 2-1 | Win | Ibrox | Smith (?), Higgins (?) |
| Mon Mar 02, 1891 | Sheffield United | A | 4-1 | Win | | Higgins (?, ?, ?), Rowan (?) |
| Thu Mar 12, 1891 | West Bromwich Albion | H | 2-3 | Loss | Town Ground | Higgins (?), Pike (?) |
| Mon Mar 16, 1891 | Aston Villa | A | 2-3 | Loss | | ? (?, ?) |
| Fri Mar 27, 1891 | Middlesbrough Ironopolis | A | 2-2 | Draw | | Russell (?), ? (?) |
| Sat Mar 28, 1891 | Newcastle East End | A | 2-1 | Win | | ? (?, ?) |
| Mon Mar 30, 1891 | Chatham | A | 2-0 | Win | | ? (?, ?) |
| Tue Mar 31, 1891 | Royal Arsenal | A | 5-0 | Win | | McCallum (?, ?), May (?), Pike (?), Smith (?) |
| Thu Apr 02, 1891 | Blackburn Rovers | H | 4-0 | Win | Town Ground | Pike (?, ?), Smith (?), McCallum (?) |
| Sat Apr 11, 1891 | Glasgow Rangers | H | 3-0 | Win | Town Ground | Russell (?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Apr 18, 1891 | Notts | H | 2-4 | Loss | Town Ground | Smith (?), Shaw (?) |
| Mon Apr 20, 1891 | Everton | A | 1-1 | Draw | | ? (?) |
| Mon Apr 27, 1891 | Burnley | A | 0-3 | Loss | Turf Moor | |
| 1891-92 | Wed Sep 09, 1891 | Mansfield | A | 4-0 | Win | | Higgins (?, ?), McPherson (?, ?) |
| Sat Sep 19, 1891 | Sunderland Albion | A | 1-0 | Win | | G King (? OG) |
| Mon Sep 21, 1891 | Everton | A | 0-2 | Loss | | |
| Fri Sep 25, 1891 | Queen's Park | A | 3-1 | Win | Hampden Park | Higgins (?), Shaw (?), ? (?) |
| Thu Oct 01, 1891 | Canadians | H | 5-0 | Win | Town Ground | Hamilton (?), Higgins (?, ?), Pike (5), Oscroft (8) |
| Sat Oct 03, 1891 | Notts | H | 3-1 | Win | Town Ground | Shaw (?), Pike (?), Higgins (?) |
| Sat Oct 10, 1891 | Sunderland Albion | H | 5-3 | Win | Town Ground | Higgins (?, ?, ?), Mason (?), Shaw (?) |
| Wed Oct 14, 1891 | Greenhalgh's | A | 6-0 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Sat Oct 24, 1891 | Kettering Town | A | 5-1 | Win | | Smith (?), Higgins (?, ?), Pike (?), ? (?) |
| Mon Oct 26, 1891 | Stoke | A | 3-0 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?) |
| Thu Nov 12, 1891 | Bolton Wanderers | H | 5-0 | Win | Town Ground | Shaw (?), Smith (?), Pike (?, ?), Higgins (?) |
| Thu Dec 03, 1891 | Stoke | H | 2-0 | Win | Town Ground | Pike (?), Russell (? pen) |
| Sat Dec 26, 1891 | Notts | A | 1-0 | Win | | Shaw (?) |
| Mon Dec 28, 1891 | Derby County | A | 0-3 | Loss | | |
| Sat Jan 02, 1892 | Darwen | A | 2-2 | Draw | | Scott (?), Shaw (?) |
| Sat Jan 23, 1892 | Aston Villa | A | 2-3 | Loss | | ? (?), Smith (?) |
| Tue Mar 01, 1892 | Rotherham Town | A | 2-2 | Draw | | Jardine (?, ?) |
| Sat Mar 12, 1892 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | A | 0-5 | Loss | | |
| Thu Mar 24, 1892 | Everton | H | 1-2 | Loss | Town Ground | Shaw (?) |
| Sat Mar 26, 1892 | Darwen | H | 3-0 | Win | Town Ground | Mason (?), Pike (?), Oscroft (?) |
| Mon Apr 04, 1892 | Celtic | A | 1-4 | Loss | | Smith (?) |
| Sat Apr 09, 1892 | Grimsby Town | A | 3-2 | Win | | Oscroft (?), Shaw (?), Russell (?) |
| Fri Apr 15, 1892 | Bolton Wanderers | A | 0-1 | Loss | | |
| 1892-93 | Thu Sep 01, 1892 | Ardwick | A | 2-2 | Draw | | Higgins (?), Pike (?) |
| Thu Sep 08, 1892 | Lincoln City | H | 3-1 | Win | Town Ground | McInnes (?, ?), Higgins (?) |
| Wed Sep 14, 1892 | Lincoln City | A | 3-2 | Win | John O'Gaunts | ? (?, ?, ?) |
| Thu Nov 03, 1892 | Sheffield United | H | 0-1 | Loss | Town Ground | |
| Sat Dec 17, 1892 | Royal Arsenal | A | 3-2 | Win | | Pike (?), Oscroft (?), Jeffrey (? OG) |
| Mon Dec 26, 1892 | Notts County | A | 1-0 | Win | | McInnes (?) |
| Sat Feb 11, 1893 | Sheffield United | A | 3-4 | Loss | | Daft (?), Higgins (?, ?) |
| Thu Feb 16, 1893 | Grimsby Town | A | 2-0 | Win | | Pike (?), McInnes (?) |
| Sat Feb 18, 1893 | Derby County | H | 3-2 | Win | Town Ground | Shaw (?), Daft (?, ?) |
| Sat Mar 04, 1893 | Small Heath | A | 3-2 | Win | | Shaw (?), McInnes (?), Pike (?) |
| Tue Mar 21, 1893 | Grantham Rovers | A | 0-0 | Draw | | |
| Sat Mar 25, 1893 | Newcastle United | A | 1-4 | Loss | | Pike (?) |
| Wed Mar 29, 1893 | Loughborough | A | 1-1 | Draw | | Pike (?) |
| Sat Apr 08, 1893 | Sheffield Wednesday | A | 1-2 | Loss | | McInnes (?) |
| Sat Apr 15, 1893 | Leicester Fosse | A | 5-1 | Win | | Shaw (?), McCallum (?), McInnes (?, ?, ?) |
| Thu Apr 20, 1893 | Derby County | H | 4-1 | Win | Town Ground | McInnes (?, ?, ?), McCallum (?) |
| Sat Apr 22, 1893 | Burton Swifts | A | 3-1 | Win | | Smith (?, ?), McCallum (?) |
| Wed Apr 26, 1893 | Chesterfield Town | A | 5-0 | Win | | McPherson (?), Smith (?), McInnes (?, ?), McCallum (?) |
| 1893-94 | Wed Sep 13, 1893 | Mansfield | A | 6-0 | Win | | McInnes (?, ?, ?), Pike (?, ?), McCallum (?) |
| Sat Nov 11, 1893 | Notts County | H | 1-2 | Loss | Town Ground | Collins (?) |
| Thu Dec 14, 1893 | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 3-1 | Win | Town Ground | McCracken (?), Collins (?), Brodie (?) |
| Sat Dec 16, 1893 | Liverpool | A | 0-3 | Loss | Anfield | |
| Tue Dec 26, 1893 | Notts County | A | 1-1 | Draw | | Higgins (?) |
| Sat Mar 10, 1894 | Small Heath | A | 2-2 | Draw | | Higgins (?), Pike (?) |
| Mon Apr 02, 1894 | Woolwich Arsenal | A | 3-1 | Win | Manor Field | McInnes (?), Collins (?), Brodie (?) |
| Wed Apr 04, 1894 | Greenhalgh's | A | 3-2 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?) |
| Wed Apr 11, 1894 | Burton Swifts | A | 2-2 | Draw | | ? (?, ?) |
| Thu Apr 26, 1894 | Grimsby Town | A | 2-2 | Draw | | Brodie (?), ? (? OG) |
| Fri Apr 27, 1894 | Bulwell United | A | 2-0 | Win | | Brodie (?), Collins (?) |
| Mon Apr 30, 1894 | Kettering Town | A | 2-1 | Win | | McCallum (?), Scott (? pen) |
| 1894-95 | Mon Sep 03, 1894 | Woolwich Arsenal | A | 2-3 | Loss | Manor Field | Rose (?), Carnelly (?) |
| Thu Sep 06, 1894 | Notts Olympic | H | 9-0 | Win | Town Ground | Pike (?, 20), Collins (?), Carnelly (?, ?, 5, 15), Rose (?, 40) |
| Tue Sep 11, 1894 | Kettering Town | A | 2-0 | Win | | Collins (?, ?) |
| Thu Sep 13, 1894 | Jardines | H | 7-0 | Win | Town Ground | Beresford (?, ?), Pike (?, ?), Roberts (? OG), Hardy (?), Jeacock (?) |
| Mon Sep 17, 1894 | Heanor Town | A | 1-0 | Win | | Carnelly (?) |
| Wed Oct 10, 1894 | Sussex Martlets | A | 8-2 | Win | Sheffield Park | Shaw (?, ?, ?), Rose (?, ?), Carnelly (?), Stewart (?), Scott (?) |
| Thu Oct 11, 1894 | Casuals | A | 4-3 | Win | | Carnelly (?), Murray (?, ?), McCracken (?) |
| Sat Oct 20, 1894 | Notts County | A | 2-0 | Win | | McInnes (?), Pike (?) |
| Fri Nov 09, 1894 | Loughborough | A | 1-2 | Loss | | Carnelly (5) |
| Wed Dec 26, 1894 | Notts County | A | 1-1 | Draw | Town Ground | McPherson (?) |
| Thu Apr 25, 1895 | Mansfield | A | 3-1 | Win | | Walker (?), Pike (?), Evans (? OG) |
| Fri Apr 26, 1895 | Hucknall | A | 5-1 | Win | | McInnes (?, ?, ?, ?), ? (?) |
| 1895-96 | Mon Sep 02, 1895 | Leicester Fosse | A | 1-0 | Win | Filbert Street | Pike (?) |
| Tue Sep 10, 1895 | Langley Mill Rangers | A | 6-1 | Win | | Hancock (?), Rose (?, ?, ?), Walker (?, ?) |
| Thu Oct 31, 1895 | Leicester Fosse | H | 5-2 | Win | Town Ground | Spencer (?, ?), McPherson (?, ?), Hancock (?) |
| Sat Nov 02, 1895 | Corinthians | A | 2-0 | Win | Queen's Club Ground | Smellie (?), Spencer (?) |
| Thu Dec 26, 1895 | Notts County | A | 1-1 | Draw | | Smellie (?) |
| Sat Jan 04, 1896 | Corinthians | H | 5-1 | Win | Town Ground | Richards (?, ?, ?), ? (?), Smellie (?) |
| Sat Feb 15, 1896 | Notts County | H | 3-1 | Win | Town Ground | Forman (?), McInnes (?), Richards (?) |
| Thu Feb 27, 1896 | Grimsby Town | H | 4-2 | Win | Town Ground | Richards (?), McInnes (?), Smellie (?), Pike (?) |
| Sat Feb 29, 1896 | Clyde | A | 3-5 | Loss | | Richards (?), Carnelly (?), Smellie (?) |
| Mon Mar 16, 1896 | Kettering Town | A | 0-1 | Loss | | |
| Wed Mar 18, 1896 | Mansfield | A | 4-1 | Win | | Carnelly (?, ?), Richards (?), Harper (? OG) |
| Mon Apr 06, 1896 | Dundee | N | 2-0 | Win | Crystal Palace | Forman (?), Shaw (?) |
| Sat Apr 11, 1896 | St. Bernards | A | 2-2 | Draw | Logie Green | Smellie (?), Pike (?) |
| Sat Apr 18, 1896 | Luton Town | A | 1-3 | Loss | | Richards (?) |
| Mon Apr 20, 1896 | Bulwell United | A | 7-3 | Win | | Smellie (?, ?, ?, ?), Pike (?, ?), Forman (?) |
| Wed Apr 22, 1896 | Sutton Town | A | 2-0 | Win | | Smellie (?), McInnes (?) |
| Mon Apr 27, 1896 | Langley Mill Rangers | A | 7-0 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Tue Apr 28, 1896 | Gresley Rovers | A | 1-1 | Draw | | ? (?) |
| 1896-97 | Thu Sep 03, 1896 | Burton Wanderers | H | 8-0 | Win | Town Ground | Richards (?, ?, ?), McInnes (?), Capes (?, ?, ?), Forman (?) |
| Thu Sep 24, 1896 | Grimsby Town | A | 2-5 | Loss | | Pike (?), Abbott (?) |
| Sat Dec 26, 1896 | Notts County | A | 2-1 | Win | | McInnes (?), Forman (?) |
| Thu Mar 25, 1897 | Grimsby Town | H | 3-0 | Win | Town Ground | Capes (?), Richards (?), McInnes (?) |
| Sat Mar 27, 1897 | Woolwich Arsenal | A | 0-1 | Loss | | |
| Sat Apr 03, 1897 | Leicester Fosse | A | 0-3 | Loss | | |
| Fri Apr 16, 1897 | Tottenham Hotspur | A | 1-1 | Draw | Northumberland Park | ? (?) |
| Mon Apr 19, 1897 | Dundee | N | 2-1 | Win | Crystal Palace | Wragg (?), Richards (?) |
| Sat Apr 24, 1897 | Lincoln City | A | 2-2 | Draw | Sincil Bank | Walker (?), Capes (?) |
| 1897-98 | Thu Sep 02, 1897 | Gainsborough Trinity | H | 5-0 | Win | City Ground (Town Ground) | McPherson (?), McInnes (?), Benbow (?, ?, ?) |
| Wed Sep 08, 1897 | Loughborough | A | 5-1 | Win | | Richards (?, ?), Capes (?, ?), Capes (?) |
| Mon Sep 13, 1897 | Langley Mill Rangers | A | 2-0 | Win | | Radford (?), ? (?) |
| Mon Sep 20, 1897 | Leicester Fosse | A | 0-4 | Loss | | |
| Wed Oct 27, 1897 | Gainsborough Trinity | A | 6-2 | Win | | Capes (?, ?, ?, ?), Simpson (?), Hancock (?) |
| Sat Dec 18, 1897 | Derby County | A | 4-2 | Win | | Forman (?), Spencer (?), Richards (?, ?) |
| Mon Dec 27, 1897 | Notts County | A | 1-0 | Win | | ? (?) |
| Tue Apr 26, 1898 | Newark | A | 5-0 | Win | | Forman (?), Iremonger (?, ?), Richards (?), McCracken (?) |
| Wed Apr 27, 1898 | Worksop Town | A | 4-1 | Win | | Forman (?), Bradshaw (?, ?), Thornley (?) |
| Thu Apr 28, 1898 | Leicester Fosse | H | 1-0 | Win | City Ground (Town Ground) | Capes (?) |
| 1898-99 | Thu Sep 22, 1898 | Grimsby Town | A | 1-0 | Win | | Radford (?) |
| Wed Mar 15, 1899 | Suffolk County | A | 3-2 | Win | | Spouncer (?), Morris (?), Suddick (?) |
| Thu Mar 16, 1899 | Kirkley And Lowestoft | A | 3-0 | Win | | Morris (?), Allsop (? pen), Spouncer (?) |
| Fri Mar 31, 1899 | Notts County | H | 1-5 | Loss | | Benbow (?) |
| Mon Apr 03, 1899 | Corinthians | N | 2-3 | Loss | Crystal Palace | Forman (33), Spouncer (45) |
| Tue Apr 04, 1899 | Coventry City | A | 1-0 | Win | | Benbow (?) |
| Sat Apr 15, 1899 | Millwall | A | 5-2 | Win | | Benbow (?), Spencer (?, ?), Forman (?, ?) |
| Thu Apr 27, 1899 | Swindon Town | A | 0-1 | Loss | | |
| 1899-00 | Mon Sep 04, 1899 | Leicester Fosse | H | 4-1 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Thu Oct 12, 1899 | Kaffirs | H | 6-3 | Win | | Capes (?), Beveridge (?), Spencer (?), ? (?, ?, ?) |
| Tue Dec 26, 1899 | Notts County | A | 4-2 | Win | | Capes (?, ?), Spouncer (?), Spencer (?) |
| Sat Mar 10, 1900 | Corinthians | A | 2-2 | Draw | Queens Club Ground | Morris (?, ?) |
| 1900-01 | Sat Nov 17, 1900 | Gainsborough Trinity | A | 4-2 | Win | | Calvey (?, ?), Morris (?, ?) |
| Fri Apr 05, 1901 | Woolwich Arsenal | A | 1-1 | Draw | | Murray (2) |
| Sat Apr 06, 1901 | Corinthians | A | 1-2 | Loss | Queens Club Ground | Capes (?) |
| Tue Apr 30, 1901 | Small Heath | A | 1-3 | Loss | | Calvey (?) |
| 1901-02 | Sat Apr 26, 1902 | Plymouth Argyle | A | 10-1 | Win | | Morris (?, ?, ?, ?, ?), Calvey (?, ?), Iremonger (?), Capes (?), Forman (?) |
| 1902-03 | Sat Sep 06, 1902 | Barrow | A | 2-0 | Win | | Morris (?), Calvey (?) |
| Mon Sep 08, 1902 | Blackpool | A | 1-0 | Win | | Calvey (?) |
| Sat Mar 14, 1903 | Cliftonville | A | 4-0 | Win | | Calvey (?, ?), Timmins (?), Spouncer (?) |
| Thu Mar 19, 1903 | Bradford City | A | 1-1 | Draw | | ? (?) |
| Tue Mar 24, 1903 | Barrow | A | 0-0 | Draw | | |
| Thu Mar 26, 1903 | Belfast Distillery | A | 4-0 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Wed Apr 29, 1903 | Tottenham Hotspur | A | 1-2 | Loss | | Calvey (?) |
| Thu Apr 30, 1903 | Ilford | A | 4-2 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?), Calvey (?) |
| 1903-04 | Mon Sep 14, 1903 | Blackpool | A | 2-1 | Win | | Sugden (?, ?) |
| Wed Sep 16, 1903 | Swindon Town | A | 3-1 | Win | | Sugden (?), Iremonger (? pen), Morris (?) |
| Thu Mar 17, 1904 | Shepherd's Bush | A | 2-0 | Win | | Sugden (?), Shearman (?) |
| Sat Mar 19, 1904 | Bradford City | A | 1-1 | Draw | | Shearman (?) |
| Thu Mar 24, 1904 | Barrow | A | 0-0 | Draw | | |
| Sat Mar 26, 1904 | Belfast Distillery | A | 4-0 | Win | | Spouncer (?, ?), Shearman (?, ?) |
| Tue Apr 05, 1904 | Darlington | A | 3-1 | Win | | Spouncer (?, ?), Sugden (?) |
| 1904-05 | Mon Oct 24, 1904 | Fulham | H | 1-1 | Draw | | Niblo (?) |
| Tue Apr 25, 1905 | Leicester Fosse | A | 2-1 | Win | | Niblo (?, ?) |
| 1906-07 | Sat Feb 02, 1907 | Northampton Town | A | 4-3 | Win | | Green (? pen), Shearman (?), Marrison (?, ?) |
| 1908-09 | Tue Sep 15, 1908 | Bradford Park Avenue | A | 2-1 | Win | Park Avenue | Shearman (?), West (?) |
| 1909-10 | Mon Mar 28, 1910 | Merthyr | A | 0-0 | Draw | | |
| Tue Mar 29, 1910 | Chesterfield | A | 0-1 | Loss | | |
| 1910-11 | Mon Sep 26, 1910 | Northampton Town | A | 0-1 | Loss | | |
| Mon Apr 17, 1911 | Queen's Park | H | 1-2 | Loss | | Derrick (?) |
| 1911-12 | Thu Oct 12, 1911 | Hillhurst Athletic | H | 4-1 | Win | | Blythe (?, ?, ?), Watkin (?) |
| Mon Jan 01, 1912 | Linfield Athletic | A | 1-2 | Loss | Windsor Park | Ford (?) |
| Sat May 04, 1912 | Oxford City | A | 3-1 | Win | | Ford (?), Lane (?), Derrick (?) |
| 1912-13 | Thu Dec 26, 1912 | Coventry City | A | 2-2 | Draw | | Revell (?), Derrick (?) |
| 1915-16 | Sat Apr 22, 1916 | Cardiff City | A | 1-2 | Loss | | Jones (?) |
| Mon May 08, 1916 | Notts County | H | 1-2 | Loss | | Sharp (20) |
| 1917-18 | Sat Dec 08, 1917 | Manton Colliery | A | 5-2 | Win | | Birch (?, ?), Godfrey (?), Godfrey (?), Wightman (?) |
| Sat Dec 15, 1917 | Bolsover | A | 4-0 | Win | | Wightman (?, ?, ?), ? (?) |
| 1918-19 | Sat Apr 19, 1919 | West Ham United | A | 0-0 | Draw | | |
| Sat Apr 26, 1919 | South Shields | A | 0-2 | Loss | | |
| 1919-20 | Tue Sep 09, 1919 | Mid Rhonda | A | 1-3 | Loss | | Derrick (?) |
| Mon Sep 15, 1919 | Sutton Town | A | 3-2 | Win | | Firth (?, ?, ?) |
| 1920-21 | Sat Mar 05, 1921 | Arsenal | A | 1-2 | Loss | | Higgins (?) |
| Sat May 14, 1921 | H Bulling XI | H | 4-3 | Win | | Hill (?, ?, ?, ?) |
| 1921-22 | Mon Sep 12, 1921 | Aberdare | A | 1-3 | Loss | | Ronald (?) |
| Fri May 05, 1922 | Boston United | A | 4-2 | Win | | Nelis (?, ?), Spaven (?), Harrison (? OG) |
| 1922-23 | Sat Feb 24, 1923 | Corinthians | H | 1-2 | Loss | | Cox (?) |
| Fri May 04, 1923 | Lincoln City | A | 2-1 | Win | | Nelis (?), Gibson (?) |
| 1923-24 | Mon Oct 08, 1923 | St Mirren | A | 1-1 | Draw | | Walker (?) |
| 1924-25 | Mon Sep 22, 1924 | Newark | A | 5-0 | Win | | Parker (?), Flood (?), Gibson (?, ?), Spaven (6) |
| Mon May 04, 1925 | Northampton Town | A | 2-1 | Win | | Walker (?, ?) |
| 1925-26 | Wed Oct 28, 1925 | Notts County | A | 2-2 | Draw | | Galloway (?, ?) |
| Mon May 03, 1926 | Northampton Town | A | 1-1 | Draw | | Stocks (?) |
| 1926-27 | Mon May 09, 1927 | Northampton Town | A | 1-0 | Win | | Stocks (?) |
| 1927-28 | Thu May 03, 1928 | Derby County | N | 1-1 | Draw | | Price (?) |
| Mon May 07, 1928 | Northampton Town | A | 2-3 | Loss | | ? (?, ?) |
| Tue May 08, 1928 | Kettering Town | A | 1-7 | Loss | | ? (?) |
| 1928-29 | Wed Nov 14, 1928 | Arsenal | A | 1-0 | Win | | Jennings (?) |
| Mon Apr 22, 1929 | Chesterfield | A | 1-1 | Draw | | Heathcock (?) |
| 1929-30 | Thu Sep 19, 1929 | Arsenal | A | 0-4 | Loss | Highbury | |
| 1930-31 | Thu Nov 06, 1930 | Oxford University | A | 4-0 | Win | | McKinlay (?), Loftus (?), Dickinson (?, ?) |
| Wed Mar 04, 1931 | Netherlands XI | A | 3-1 | Win | | Dent (? pen), Dickinson (?), Smith (?) |
| 1931-32 | Mon Apr 18, 1932 | Peterborough and Fletton United | ? | 2-1 | Win | | Chambers (?), Dent (?) |
| Mon Apr 25, 1932 | Peterborough and Fletton United | A | 2-1 | Win | London Road | Dickinson (27), Jones (47) |
| Wed Apr 27, 1932 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | A | 3-1 | Win | Molineux | ? (?, ?, ?) |
| Mon May 02, 1932 | Chesterfield | A | 4-2 | Win | Saltergate | Dent (?), Dickinson (?, 4), Heslop (44) |
| 1932-33 | Wed May 03, 1933 | Bristol Rovers | A | 0-2 | Loss | Trowbridge | |
| 1933-34 | Thu May 03, 1934 | Gorleston | A | 5-2 | Win | Gorleston Recreation Ground | Pugh (?, ?), Dent (?, ?), Simpson (?) |
| 1938-39 | Sat Aug 20, 1938 | Notts County | H | 4-1 | Win | | Getty (?), Dyson (?), Crawshaw (?), Brown (?) |
| 1939-40 | Sat Aug 19, 1939 | Notts County | A | 1-1 | Draw | | Fryer (?) |
| Sat Sep 16, 1939 | Peterborough United | A | 3-4 | Loss | | Fryer (?), McCall (?, ?) |
| Sat Sep 23, 1939 | Grimsby Town | H | 1-2 | Loss | | Munro (? pen) |
| Sat Sep 30, 1939 | Lincoln City | A | 6-0 | Win | | Thomas (?, ?), McCall (?, ?), Drury (?), Mills (?) |
| Sat Oct 07, 1939 | Sheffield Wednesday | H | 1-2 | Loss | | McCall (?) |
| Sat Oct 14, 1939 | Notts County | H | 2-1 | Win | | Hinchcliffe (?), Lager (?) |
| Sat Nov 04, 1939 | Chelmsford | A | 4-1 | Win | | McCall (?, ?), Drury (?, ?) |
| Sat Nov 18, 1939 | Bristol City | A | 9-3 | Win | | Hinchcliffe (?, ?, ?), McCall (?, ?), Hunter (?), Drury (?), Maund (?), Walker (?) |
| Sat Dec 16, 1939 | Stockport County | H | 6-0 | Win | | Beaumont (?, ?, ?), Drury (?, ?), Walker (?) |
| Tue Dec 26, 1939 | Leicester City | H | 3-1 | Win | | McCall (?), Drury (?), Hinchcliffe (?) |
| Sat Dec 30, 1939 | Port Vale | A | 3-1 | Win | | Hinchcliffe (?, ?), Drury (?) |
| Sat Jan 13, 1940 | Birmingham International XI | H | 0-1 | Loss | | |
| Sat Mar 16, 1940 | Army XI | H | 3-0 | Win | | Peacock (?), Drury (?), Hinchcliffe (?) |
| Sat Apr 13, 1940 | Stoke City | H | 2-3 | Loss | | Trim (?), Drury (?) |
| 1940-41 | Sat Oct 19, 1940 | Lincoln City | A | 3-2 | Win | Sincil Bank | Langton (?), Smith (?, ?) |
| Sat Nov 09, 1940 | RAF XI | H | 1-4 | Loss | | ? (?) |
| Sat Nov 30, 1940 | RAF XI | A | 4-1 | Win | | Peacock (?, ?), Adams (?), ? (?) |
| 1941-42 | Sat Sep 27, 1941 | RAF XI | H | 1-2 | Loss | | Iverson (?) |
| Sat Oct 25, 1941 | REVCO Electric | A | 1-5 | Loss | | Mee (?) |
| Sat Nov 01, 1941 | RAF XI | H | 3-1 | Win | | Mee (?), Broome (?, ?) |
| Thu Dec 25, 1941 | Mansfield Town | H | 3-0 | Win | | Mee (?), Ward (?), Slack (?) |
| Sat Apr 25, 1942 | RAF XI | H | 4-0 | Win | | Collins (?, ?, ?, ?) |
| 1942-43 | Mon Apr 26, 1943 | Doncaster Rovers | A | 3-3 | Draw | | Clare (?), Skelton (?), Bett (?) |
| 1944-45 | Wed May 09, 1945 | Derby County | A | 2-2 | Draw | Baseball Ground | Leverton (?, ?) |
| 1945-46 | Wed Aug 15, 1945 | Notts County | H | 3-2 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?) |
| Thu Aug 16, 1945 | Derby County | H | 1-4 | Loss | | ? (?) |
| Wed Oct 24, 1945 | British Army Of The Rhine | N | 1-4 | Loss | Flensburg | North (?) |
| 1946-47 | Wed Nov 06, 1946 | Combined Services XI | A | 2-2 | Draw | | Mee (?), Edwards (?) |
| 1947-48 | Sat Jan 24, 1948 | Arsenal | H | 2-3 | Loss | | Wilkins (? pen), Barks (?) |
| Sat Feb 07, 1948 | Crystal Palace | A | 0-1 | Loss | | |
| 1949-50 | Tue Apr 25, 1950 | Tilbury | H | 1-1 | Draw | | ? (?) |
| Sat May 13, 1950 | Gooi Hilversum | A | 1-0 | Win | | Ardron (?) |
| Thu May 18, 1950 | Sparta Rotterdam | A | 1-0 | Win | | Gager (? pen) |
| Sun May 21, 1950 | Gottingen 05 | A | 2-2 | Draw | | Love (?), Ardron (?) |
| Tue May 23, 1950 | Werder Bremen | A | 1-5 | Loss | | Gager (? pen) |
| Thu May 25, 1950 | Osnabruck | A | 2-2 | Draw | | Hutchinson (?), Love (?) |
| Sun May 28, 1950 | RC Malines | A | 0-6 | Loss | | |
| 1950-51 | Sat May 12, 1951 | RC Malines | H | 3-1 | Win | | Capel (?), Love (?), Johnson (?) |
| 1951-52 | Sat Feb 23, 1952 | Bolton Wanderers | H | 3-3 | Draw | | Moore (?), Capel (?), Ardron (?) |
| Mon Apr 07, 1952 | Bexhill-on-Sea | A | 12-1 | Win | | Moore (?, ?, ?, ?, ?), Ardron (?, ?, ?), Leverton (?, ?), Capel (?), Morley (?) |
| Wed May 14, 1952 | Guernsey XI | A | 5-2 | Win | | Ardron (?, ?), Collindridge (?, ?), Leverton (?) |
| 1952-53 | Sat Nov 15, 1952 | Leeds United | A | 0-0 | Aba | Elland Road | |
| Wed Apr 15, 1953 | Clyde | H | 6-0 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Thu Apr 30, 1953 | Mansfield Town | A | 1-1 | Draw | | ? (?) |
| 1953-54 | Sat Jan 30, 1954 | Aston Villa | H | 0-2 | Loss | | |
| Tue Apr 27, 1954 | West Midlands XI | N | 7-1 | Win | | Ardron (?, ?), Thompson (?, ?), Collindridge (?), Capel (?), Moore (?) |
| Wed Apr 28, 1954 | Rushden Town | A | 5-2 | Win | | Capel (?, ?), Thompson (?), McLaren (?), ? (? OG) |
| 1954-55 | Mon Mar 21, 1955 | East Fife | A | 5-1 | Win | | Small (?), Wilson (?, ?, ?), Burkitt (?) |
| Thu May 05, 1955 | Nottingham Rugby Club | H | 3-0 | Win | | Langford (?), Burkitt (?), Thomas (?) |
| 1955-56 | Wed Apr 25, 1956 | Arsenal | H | 1-1 | Draw | | Lishman (?) |
| Fri May 04, 1956 | Nottingham Rugby Club | H | 4-3 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?) |
| 1956-57 | Mon Oct 15, 1956 | Coventry City | A | 2-3 | Loss | | Jones (?), Kirk (? OG) |
| Wed May 08, 1957 | Norwich City | A | 7-2 | Win | Carrow Road | Imlach (?, ?, ?), Wilson (?, ?), Morley (?), McKinlay (?) |
| 1957-58 | Wed May 14, 1958 | Berlin | A | 4-3 | Win | West Berlin Post Stadium | Quigley (?), Gray (?), Baily (?, ?) |
| Sat May 17, 1958 | RW Oberhausen | A | 3-1 | Win | | Gray (?), Wilson (?, ?) |
| Sun May 18, 1958 | Flamengo | N | 2-2 | Draw | Stade de Sclessin | Wilson (25), Baily (70) |
| Mon May 19, 1958 | Fiorentina | A | 0-0 | Draw | | |
| Wed May 21, 1958 | Netherlands XI | A | 0-1 | Loss | | |
| 1958-59 | Wed May 20, 1959 | Sporting Lisbon | A | 1-0 | Win | Estadio Jose Alvalade | Gray (32 pen) |
| Sun May 24, 1959 | Oviedo | A | 0-1 | Loss | Carlos Tartiere Stadium | |
| Wed May 27, 1959 | Valencia | A | 1-0 | Win | Mestalla Stadium | Barrett (33) |
| Thu May 28, 1959 | Atletico Madrid | A | 1-6 | Loss | Estadio Metropolitano de Madrid | Barrett (28) |
| Sat May 30, 1959 | Athletico Bilbao | A | 0-3 | Loss | Estadio Ramon de Carranza | |
| 1959-60 | Wed Oct 21, 1959 | Norwich City | A | 1-3 | Loss | Carrow Road | Rowland (86) |
| Mon Oct 26, 1959 | Notts County | A | 1-3 | Loss | Meadow Lane | ? (?) |
| 1960-61 | Thu Mar 02, 1961 | Watford | A | 1-1 | Draw | | Rowland (?) |
| Mon Mar 20, 1961 | Peterborough United | A | 1-4 | Loss | | ? (?) |
| Mon Apr 10, 1961 | Barrow | A | 2-1 | Win | | Cobb (?, ?) |
| Sat May 13, 1961 | Karlovy Vary | A | 4-0 | Win | | ? (?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Tue May 16, 1961 | Sparta Prague | A | 1-1 | Draw | | Rowland (?) |
| Sun May 21, 1961 | Sp. Hradek Kralova | A | 2-1 | Win | | Julians (?), Iley (?) |
| Wed May 24, 1961 | Dynamo Zilina | A | 2-0 | Win | | Booth (?), Le Flem (?) |
| 1961-62 | Mon Nov 27, 1961 | Stockport County | A | 2-4 | Loss | | Palmer (?), Quigley (?) |
| 1962-63 | Mon Oct 22, 1962 | Stockport County | A | 6-0 | Win | | Julians (?), Addison (?), Le Flem (?), Quigley (?), Gray (?), Hockey (?) |
| 1963-64 | Mon Apr 20, 1964 | New Zealand XI | H | 8-0 | Win | | Wignall (?, ?, ?), Addison (?, ?), Hinton (?, ?), Storey-Moore (?) |
| Sat May 02, 1964 | Hertha Berlin | A | 3-0 | Win | | Addison (?, ?, ?) |
| Wed May 06, 1964 | Basle | A | 6-0 | Win | | Wignall (?, ?), Newton (?, ?), Addison (?), ? (? OG) |
| Thu May 07, 1964 | Lucerne | A | 4-0 | Win | | Vowden (?), Pleat (?), Newton (?), Barnwell (?) |
| Sat May 09, 1964 | Winterthur | A | 5-1 | Win | | Barnwell (?), Wignall (?, ?), Pleat (?), Vowden (?) |
| 1964-65 | Sat Aug 15, 1964 | Brentford | A | 3-0 | Win | | Addison (?, ?, ?) |
| Mon Apr 12, 1965 | Celtic | H | 3-0 | Win | | Addison (?), Hinton (?), ? (?) |
| Sun May 02, 1965 | Rapid Vienna | A | 2-0 | Win | | Crowe (?), Addison (?) |
| Fri May 14, 1965 | Hartford SC | A | - | | | |
| Sun May 16, 1965 | Ukrainian Nationals | A | 3-2 | Win | | Barnwell (?, ?), Kear (?) |
| Wed May 19, 1965 | Boston Metros | A | 4-2 | Win | | Storey-Moore (?, ?), Hinton (?, ?) |
| Sun May 23, 1965 | Hannover 96 | A | 1-3 | Loss | | Hinton (?) |
| Thu May 27, 1965 | CYC All Stars | A | 6-1 | Win | | Addison (?), Hinton (?, ?), Wilson (?), Crowe (?, ?) |
| Sun May 30, 1965 | Hannover 96 | A | 2-0 | Win | | Wilson (?, ?) |
| Wed Jun 02, 1965 | Hannover 96 | A | 6-2 | Win | | Crowe (?), Addison (?), Barnwell (?), Hinton (? pen, ?, ?) |
| Sat Jun 05, 1965 | Hannover 96 | A | 2-1 | Win | | Hinton (?), Addison (?) |
| Wed Jun 09, 1965 | British Columbia All Stars | A | 2-0 | Win | | Barnwell (?), Hinton (?) |
| Sat Jun 12, 1965 | Hibernian | A | 1-2 | Loss | | Addison (?) |
| Mon Jun 14, 1965 | Toronto XI | A | 1-0 | Win | | Barnwell (? pen) |
| 1965-66 | Sat Aug 14, 1965 | Coventry City | A | 3-4 | Loss | | Newton (55), Barnwell (61), Hinton (88) |
| Tue Sep 28, 1965 | Valencia | H | 1-1 | Draw | | Crowe (? pen) |
| Mon Oct 04, 1965 | Doncaster Rovers | A | 6-1 | Win | | Crowe (?), Barnwell (?), Newton (?), ? (?), Addison (?), Watton (? OG) |
| Mon Nov 01, 1965 | Nuneaton Borough | A | 0-0 | Draw | | |
| Fri Mar 04, 1966 | Crystal Palace | A | 1-4 | Loss | | Newton (?) |
| Tue Mar 29, 1966 | Partick Thistle | H | 1-1 | Draw | | Newton (?) |
| Wed May 18, 1966 | Standard Liege | A | 3-4 | Loss | | Addison (?), Baker (?), Crowe (?) |
| Sun May 22, 1966 | Valenciennes | A | 1-4 | Loss | | Baker (?) |
| Tue May 24, 1966 | SCO Angers | A | 3-1 | Win | | Storey-Moore (?), Barnwell (?), Taylor (?) |
| 1966-67 | Sat Aug 06, 1966 | Hibernian | A | 2-3 | Loss | | Baker (?, ?) |
| Sun Aug 07, 1966 | Dundalk | A | 5-0 | Win | | Taylor (?, ?, ?), Addison (?), Hennessey (? pen) |
| Sat Aug 13, 1966 | Varna XI | H | 0-1 | Loss | | |
| Tue Nov 29, 1966 | Dukla Prague | H | 3-1 | Win | | Hinton (?), Newton (?), Kear (?) |
| Wed May 17, 1967 | Barcelona | A | 2-1 | Win | | Wignall (?), Lyons (?) |
| Wed May 24, 1967 | Valencia | A | 0-1 | Loss | | |
| 1967-68 | Tue Mar 05, 1968 | Derby County | H | 1-2 | Loss | | Lyons (?) |
| 1968-69 | Sat Jan 25, 1969 | Norwich City | A | 1-1 | Draw | | Barnwell (?) |
| 1969-70 | Mon Nov 17, 1969 | Rot-Weiss Essen | H | 1-0 | Win | | Lyons (?) |
| Tue Apr 14, 1970 | Den Haag | H | 2-4 | Loss | | Hilley (?, ?) |
| Tue May 12, 1970 | Den Haag | A | 2-3 | Loss | | Hilley (?), Ingram (?) |
| 1971-72 | Sat Aug 07, 1971 | Hannover 96 | H | 3-2 | Win | | Storey-Moore (?), Martin (?, ?) |
| 1972-73 | Wed Jun 20, 1973 | Benfica | A | 0-3 | Loss | Estadio da Luz | |
| Sat Jun 23, 1973 | FC Porto | A | 1-1 | Draw | Estadio das Antas | McKenzie (?) |
| 1973-74 | Wed Sep 26, 1973 | Derby County | A | 1-1 | Draw | Baseball Ground | ? (?) |
| 1974-75 | Mon Apr 14, 1975 | Worksop Town | A | 2-1 | Win | Sandy Lane | ? (?, ?) |
| Mon Apr 21, 1975 | Grantham Town | A | 2-1 | Win | London Road | ? (?, ?) |
| Mon Apr 28, 1975 | Biggleswade Town | A | 6-1 | Win | Fairfield Road | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| 1975-76 | Mon Nov 17, 1975 | Hartlepool United | A | 0-0 | Draw | Victoria Park | |
| Tue Dec 09, 1975 | Qatar XI | A | 1-1 | Draw | | Richardson (?) |
| Mon Feb 02, 1976 | Corby Town | A | 2-1 | Win | Steel Park | ? (?, ?) |
| Tue Apr 06, 1976 | Louth United | A | 6-1 | Win | Marshlands | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Fri Apr 30, 1976 | CD Severence | A | 10-1 | Win | | Butlin (?, ?, ?, ?), Bowyer (?, ?, ?), Barrett (?), Curran (? pen), Middleton (?) |
| 1976-77 | Wed Oct 13, 1976 | Grantham Town | A | 3-1 | Win | London Road | Haslegrave (?), Withe (?), Burke (?) |
| Wed Mar 16, 1977 | Grantham Town | A | 2-1 | Win | London Road | Woodcock (?), O'Neill (?) |
| Mon May 09, 1977 | Derby County | A | 0-1 | Loss | Baseball Ground | |
| Thu May 12, 1977 | Peterborough United | A | 5-2 | Win | London Road | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| 1977-78 | Tue Nov 22, 1977 | Maccabi Tel Aviv | A | 6-1 | Win | Bloomfield Stadium | Anderson (?), McGovern (?), Lloyd (?), Woodcock (?, ?), ? (?) |
| 1978-79 | Tue Dec 05, 1978 | Dynamo Zagreb | A | 2-1 | Win | Stadion Maksimir | Birtles (?, ?) |
| 1979-80 | Tue Nov 27, 1979 | Cairo XI | A | 3-1 | Win | | Birtles (?, ?), Francis (?) |
| Tue Dec 18, 1979 | Cologne | A | 1-1 | Draw | Mungersdorfer Stadion | Lloyd (?) |
| Tue Jan 08, 1980 | Gravesend and Northfleet | A | 6-1 | Win | Stonebridge Road | Birtles (?, ?), Francis (?), Robertson (?), Mills (?, ?) |
| Fri Apr 11, 1980 | Emirates SC | A | 4-1 | Win | Emirates Club Stadium | Needham (?), Francis (?, ?, ?) |
| Sun Apr 13, 1980 | Murrahaq SC | A | 8-2 | Win | Al Muharraq Stadium | Needham (?), Francis (?, ?), Birtles (?, ?), Anderson (?), Robertson (?), ? (? OG) |
| Sat May 10, 1980 | Stade Brestois | A | 1-1 | Draw | Stade Francis-Le Ble | McGovern (?) |
| 1980-81 | Mon Sep 08, 1980 | Notts County | A | 3-2 | Win | Meadow Lane | ? (?, ?, ?) |
| Mon Oct 13, 1980 | Tampa Bay Rowdies | H | 7-1 | Win | | Needham (?, ?), Mills (?, ?, ?), Ponte (?), Burns (?) |
| Wed Dec 10, 1980 | Grantham Town | A | 6-1 | Win | London Road | Francis (?, ?, ?), Walsh (?), Ward (?), Anderson (?) |
| Sun Jan 11, 1981 | Paris St Germain | A | 0-2 | Loss | Parc des Princes | |
| Thu Jan 15, 1981 | Torquay United | A | - | | Plainmoor | |
| Wed Feb 04, 1981 | Red Star Belgrade | H | 1-3 | Loss | | Francis (?) |
| Tue Apr 07, 1981 | Kettering Town | A | 5-2 | Win | Rockingham Road | Robertson (? pen, ? pen), Wallace (?, ?), Francis (?) |
| Tue Apr 14, 1981 | Cardiff City | A | 2-1 | Win | Ninian Park | Robertson (?, ?) |
| Sun May 10, 1981 | Real Madrid | A | 0-2 | Loss | Bernabeu Stadium | |
| Tue May 19, 1981 | Real Mallorca | A | 5-1 | Win | Lluis Sitjar Stadium | Mills (?), Wallace (?, ?), Ward (?), Gray (? pen) |
| 1981-82 | Sun Oct 11, 1981 | Vancouver Whitecaps | H | 2-2 | Draw | | Proctor (?), Hodge (?) |
| Tue Oct 13, 1981 | Valerengen | A | 2-1 | Win | Ullevaal Stadion | Fashanu (?), Wallace (?) |
| Wed Nov 04, 1981 | Grantham Town | A | 5-2 | Win | London Road | Hodge (?, ?, ?), ? (?), Proctor (?) |
| Tue Dec 29, 1981 | Rotherham United | A | 0-2 | Loss | Millmoor | |
| Mon Jan 04, 1982 | Luton Town | H | 5-1 | Win | | Ward (?, ?), Wallace (?), Walsh (?), Gray (?) |
| Fri Jan 15, 1982 | Torquay United | A | 1-2 | Loss | Plainmoor | Ward (?) |
| Tue Jan 26, 1982 | Scunthorpe United | A | 2-1 | Win | Old Show Ground | Proctor (?), Wallace (?) |
| Fri Mar 05, 1982 | Norwich City | A | 1-1 | Draw | Carrow Road | Anderson (?) |
| Wed May 19, 1982 | Burton Albion | A | 7-1 | Win | Eton Park | Fashanu (?, ?, ?), Hodge (?, ?, ?), Davenport (?) |
| Sat May 22, 1982 | Kuwait XI | A | 1-1 | Draw | | Fashanu (?) |
| 1982-83 | Mon Nov 01, 1982 | Al-Qadsiya | A | 1-1 | Draw | Mohammed Al-Hamad Stadium | Bowyer (?) |
| Wed Nov 03, 1982 | Al-Hilal | A | 8-1 | Win | King Fahd International Stadium | Birtles (?, ?, ?), Wallace (?, ?, ?), Hodge (?), Fairclough (?) |
| Mon Nov 15, 1982 | Poole Town | A | 4-3 | Win | Tatnam | Proctor (?), Birtles (?), Bowyer (?), Kendal (?) |
| Mon Dec 06, 1982 | Stamford | A | 8-2 | Win | The Zeeco Stadium | Walsh (?, 4), Wallace (?, ?), Birtles (?), Kendal (?), Proctor (?, 47) |
| Mon Dec 13, 1982 | Malta XI | A | 2-1 | Win | Marsa Stadium | Birtles (?), Hodge (?) |
| Wed Feb 02, 1983 | Palma Mallorca | A | 0-2 | Loss | Iberostar Estadio | |
| Wed Mar 09, 1983 | Algeria XI | A | 1-3 | Loss | | Wallace (?) |
| Tue Apr 19, 1983 | Grimsby Town | A | 0-0 | Draw | Blundell Park | |
| Sun Apr 24, 1983 | Darlington | A | 2-1 | Win | Feethams | Walsh (?), Proctor (?) |
| Tue Apr 26, 1983 | Huddersfield Town | A | 1-1 | Draw | Leeds Road | Davenport (?) |
| Tue May 10, 1983 | Kettering Town | A | 5-1 | Win | Latimer Park | Wallace (?, ?, ?), Proctor (?), Davenport (?) |
| Fri May 27, 1983 | Manic de Montreal | A | 4-3 | Win | | Walsh (? pen), Davenport (?), Hodge (?, ?) |
| Sun May 29, 1983 | Toronto Blizzard | A | 1-2 | Loss | Varsity Stadium | Davenport (?) |
| 1983-84 | Sun Jan 29, 1984 | Oman XI | A | 5-1 | Win | Police Stadium | Wigley (?), Walsh (? pen), Hodge (?), Wallace (?), Gunn (?) |
| Tue Jan 31, 1984 | Oman XI | A | 3-1 | Win | | Wallace (?), Thijssen (?, ?) |
| Tue May 01, 1984 | Botev Vratza | A | 2-0 | Win | Marsa Stadium | Anderson (?), Fairclough (?) |
| Sun May 27, 1984 | Western Australia | A | 4-1 | Win | Lake Monger Velodrome | Davenport (?), Birtles (?), Bowyer (?), Mills (?) |
| Wed May 30, 1984 | Australia A | A | 1-1 | Draw | Hindmarsh | Anderson (?) |
| Sun Jun 03, 1984 | Manchester United | N | 0-1 | Loss | Melbourne Cricket Ground | |
| Thu Jun 07, 1984 | Australia A | A | 2-2 | Draw | Lang Park | Hodge (? pen), Bowyer (?) |
| Mon Jun 11, 1984 | Australia B | A | 0-0 | Draw | Sydney Cricket Ground | |
| 1984-85 | Sun Nov 18, 1984 | Australia | H | 0-0 | Draw | | |
| Mon Dec 10, 1984 | Al-Hilal | A | 2-0 | Win | King Fahd International Stadium | Hodge (?), Riley (?) |
| Wed Dec 12, 1984 | Ittihad | A | 1-1 | Draw | | Fairclough (?) |
| Mon Feb 11, 1985 | Iraq XI | A | 0-2 | Loss | | |
| Wed Feb 13, 1985 | Iraq XI | A | 1-1 | Draw | | Hodge (?) |
| 1985-86 | Mon Oct 14, 1985 | Bristol Rovers | A | 1-1 | Draw | Eastville Stadium | Clough (?) |
| Tue Oct 22, 1985 | Borrowash Victoria | A | 3-1 | Win | Watkinson Construction Bowl | ? (?, ?, ?) |
| Wed Jan 15, 1986 | PSV Eindhoven | H | 0-4 | Loss | | |
| Fri Jan 24, 1986 | Newcastle United | N | 3-1 | Win | Somerset Cricket Club Ground | Campbell (?, ?), Bowyer (?) |
| Tue Mar 04, 1986 | Stoke City | A | 1-2 | Loss | Victoria Ground | Clough (9) |
| Wed Mar 19, 1986 | Real Sociedad U-21 | H | 2-1 | Win | | Campbell (9, 52) |
| Mon Mar 24, 1986 | Ottery St Mary | A | 5-1 | Win | Washbrook Meadows | Campbell (?, ?), Bowyer (?), Clough (? pen), Birtles (?) |
| Tue Apr 15, 1986 | Real Sociedad | A | 3-1 | Win | Anoeta Stadium | Campbell (?), Rice (?), Carr (25) |
| Mon May 05, 1986 | Derry City | A | 2-1 | Win | Baseball Ground | Walsh (35), Carr (88) |
| 1986-87 | Tue Oct 14, 1986 | Notts County | A | 5-2 | Win | Meadow Lane | Birtles (?, ?, ?, ?), Mills (?) |
| Tue Nov 25, 1986 | Plymouth Argyle | A | 1-6 | Loss | Home Park | Clough (?) |
| Tue Mar 31, 1987 | VF Frolunda | A | 2-1 | Win | Marsa Stadium | Pearce (? pen), Clough (?) |
| Mon May 11, 1987 | Spartak Varna XI | A | 1-1 | Draw | Yuri Gagarin Stadium | Wilkinson (?) |
| 1987-88 | Mon Nov 23, 1987 | Saudi Arabia XI | A | 1-1 | Draw | | Gaynor (?) |
| Sun May 08, 1988 | Lincoln City | A | 2-2 | Draw | Sincil Bank | Parker (?), Clough (? pen) |
| 1988-89 | Mon Sep 12, 1988 | Heart Of Midlothian | A | 3-1 | Win | Tynecastle Stadium | Gaynor (24), Mike Galloway (27 OG), Parker (55) |
| Mon Nov 21, 1988 | Grantham Town | A | 4-1 | Win | London Road | Clough (?, ?), Parker (?), Chapman (?) |
| 1989-90 | Mon Oct 09, 1989 | King's Lynn | A | 5-0 | Win | The Walks | Chapman (?, ?), Sheridan (?), Parker (?), Crosby (?) |
| Tue Jan 09, 1990 | Auxerre | A | 2-2 | Draw | Stade l'Abbe-Deschamps | Orlygsson (?), Walker (?) |
| 1991-92 | Thu May 07, 1992 | Glenavon | A | 5-1 | Win | Mourneview Park | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| 1992-93 | Mon Sep 14, 1992 | Derby County | H | 0-2 | Loss | | |
| Sun Mar 07, 1993 | Jersey Portugese | A | 10-1 | Win | | Bannister (?, ?), Crosby (?, ?), Rosario (?, ?, ?, ?), Clough (?), Laws (?) |
| 1993-94 | Tue May 10, 1994 | Mansfield Town | A | 3-3 | Draw | Field Mill | Crossley (? pen), Collymore (?, ?) |
| 1994-95 | Tue Nov 15, 1994 | Northampton Town | A | 1-2 | Loss | Sixfields Stadium | Woan (?) |
| Wed Feb 15, 1995 | Dynamo Zagreb | A | 2-1 | Win | Stadion Maksimir | Bohinen (?), Lee (?) |
| Wed Apr 19, 1995 | Crusaders | A | 2-1 | Win | | Howe (?), Stratford (?) |
| Wed May 17, 1995 | Birmingham City | A | 4-1 | Win | St. Andrews | Stone (?), Collymore (?), Lee (?), Bull (?) |
| Sun May 21, 1995 | Singapore XI | A | 3-1 | Win | | Collymore (?), Woan (?), Bull (?) |
| Wed May 24, 1995 | Adelaide | A | 1-1 | Draw | | ? (?) |
| Sat May 27, 1995 | Western Australia | A | 1-2 | Loss | | ? (?) |
| 1997-98 | Mon Apr 27, 1998 | Shrewsbury Town | A | 1-4 | Loss | Gay Meadow | Stone (?) |
| Wed May 06, 1998 | Chelsea | A | 3-3 | Draw | Stamford Bridge | ? (?, ?, ?) |
| Fri May 08, 1998 | Middlesbrough | A | 5-0 | Win | Riverside Stadium | ? (?, ?, ?, ?, ?) |
| 1998-99 | Wed Oct 07, 1998 | Dagenham and Redbridge | A | 4-0 | Win | | Quashie (?), Darcheville (?), Freedman (?), ? (?) |
| 2001-02 | Tue Oct 02, 2001 | Southwell City | A | 4-1 | Win | War Memorial Recreation Ground | ? (?, ?, ?, ?) |
| Tue May 07, 2002 | Le Mans | A | 0-0 | Draw | MMArena | |
| Thu May 09, 2002 | Le Havre | A | 0-0 | Draw | Stade Oceane | |
| 2008-09 | Thu Oct 09, 2008 | Republic of Ireland XI | A | 0-2 | Loss | Dalymount Park Dublin | |
| 2019-20 | Tue Jun 09, 2020 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | A | 2-0 | Win | Molineux | Walker (? pen), Bostock John (?) |
